Housing Court Woes
As a housing organizer in Bushwick, Brooklyn, Yolanda Coca butts heads with the most difficult judges while defending the rights of tenants.
And the deck is stacked against tenants in housing court. According to the New York County Lawyers Association, of the approximate 350,000 residential cases filed in housing court each year, only 11.9 percent of the tenant litigants had legal representation. The rest are pro se – forced to represent themselves. If they are lucky they will find a housing advocate like Coca to shepherd them through the process.
“In the beginning the landlords’ lawyers wanted to intimidate me, but when I demonstrated my knowledge, they warmed up,” said Coca, who has been advocating for tenants in housing court for 11 years. “Many judges know and respect me.”
Coca’s biggest challenge in housing court is the “mean attitude” of some judges and the landlord lawyers.
Pro se tenant Pat Senior knows what Coca is talking about. In 2005, Senior says, Judge George Heymann evicted her from her apartment at University Towers in downtown Brooklyn on a non-payment case in which the papers were never properly served. Senior says Judge Heymann was late to court and when she asked to be able to ask questions and defend herself Judge Heymann had a “nasty, sharp tone.” Senior claimed exchanges between her and Heymann deteriorated so badly that she tried to go before a different judge.
“I asked for him to be recused because he was biased,” Senior said.
Heymann’s tardiness has caught the attention of tenant lawyers and advocates. Housing court usually opens at 9:30, Monday through Friday.
“I noted it in my book; I was shocked at how late he was,” said a rookie housing attorney who wished not to give his name for fear of retaliation. “When his court is open and he’s not there, nothing can move forward.”
On July 13, the judge waltzed in around 10:30 with a coffee cup in one hand and a calculator in the other. Public housing tenants filled the courtroom almost to capacity waiting for the judge to hear their cases. I counted over 90 cases on Heymann’s schedule but the judge didn’t call his first case until 11:20.
Attorneys and advocates say tardiness is an accepted norm in Brooklyn housing court and judges do have paperwork that keeps them busy.
Though Coca has mixed feelings about Heymann, her biggest nemesis has been Judge Dawn Jimenez. Jimenez was appointed to her housing court position five years ago after working as an attorney at Borah, Goldstein, Altschuler & Schwartz, a large law firm that represents landlords.
“When I first came to her court she did everything to make my life difficult,” Coca said. “I shook my head about a decision and she yelled, ‘Don’t come back to my courtroom.’”
Judge Heymann is up for re-appointment in housing court this month and Judge Jimenez is looking to be appointed to another position in civil court. To make a complaint, call City-Wide Task Force on Housing Court, Inc. 212-962-4266.
Bennett Baumer is a tenant organizer for the Metropolitan Council on Housing (metcouncil.net). Contact: Bennett@metcouncil. net
ART: Ryan Dunsmuir


Housing court judges and lawyers show up everyday with empty briefcases, a cup of coffee (probably mixed with Kahlua) and a calculator. Housing court is a debt collection agency. How does the court get so stacked with crappy judges?
Dear Mr. Baumer,
I recently read your June 20th article on housing court judges and thought you may find the May 17th letter (below) detailing Judge George Heymann’s procedural conduct of interest. For the past nine months, I have spent countless hours in housing court, attempting to help a severely disadvantaged elderly lady navigate the court system while finding pro bono representation for her. Since Judge Heymann was the initial judge on this tenant’s case, I spent scores of hours observing his conduct, conduct–listening to case after case recorded on archived tape and sitting in the back of his courtroom–in an effort to understand the complicated circumstances of her case. During those nine months, I studied Judge Heymann’s conduct, as well as that of other housing judges, attorneys, and clerks, and unbeknownst to them, felt compelled to send my observations to Chief Administrative Judge, the Honorable Jonathan Lippman. Below is the letter that was sent.
Hon. Jonathan Lippman May 17, 2006
Chief Administrative Judge
25 Beaver Street
New York, New York 10004
Re: Hon. George M. Heymann
Civil Court of the City of New York
141 Livingston Street
New York, New York 11201
Dear Judge Lippman:
As a former investigative producer for network television (NBC News, Dateline; ABC News, Turning Point; CBS News, 60 Minutes), I often had to reach out to government offices/courts in order to gather information for our reports. Many of the calls I made were on behalf of such notable correspondents as Mike Wallace, Barbara Walters, Diane Sawyer, and Jane Pauley. When calling on behalf of these prominent individuals, it was not uncommon to receive red carpet treatment.
But a few weeks ago, I entered the Civil Court of the City of New York, Kings County Housing Court as an “ordinary citizen”, in an attempt to obtain information and clarification about a holdover proceeding pending against a friend of mine, an elderly women facing imminent eviction. I am delighted to report that the exemplary treatment we have repeatedly received from the Honorable George M. Heymann—the initial Judge on the case—has astounded us both.
Although the case was no longer his responsibility, Judge Heymann took the time on more than one occasion, either during his lunch hour or upon completion of the day’s calendar, to answer our questions and provide us with general information that enabled us to understand the otherwise daunting and overwhelming court system. And while Judge Heymann made it clear that he could not provide us with any legal advise or discuss the merits or substance of the case, exparte, the degree of humanity, concern, integrity, professionalism, intelligence, expeditiousness, patience, and kindness inherent in his treatment of us, as well as all those we observed around him, has impressed us to the point of near speechlessness.
While red carpet treatment is not uncommon for network journalists, the manner in which Judge Heymann handled the concerns of a sweet little old lady has been extraordinary—not to mention, inspirational.
We civilians often neglect to take the time to provide substantive feedback about our interactions with government agents, or court personnel, but Judge George M. Heymann truly deserves infinite accolades.
If such manner is indicative of the way he treats all the litigants that appear before him, we cannot but laud his efforts and yours for having appointed him.
Our warmest thanks,
Maria Di Battista and Jeannine Dillon
cc: Hon. Fern A.Fisher
Hon. Karen B. Rothenberg
Jeannine Dillon,
I am glad that the elderly tenant in jeopardy of being evicted had an advocate like your self. Most tenants do not have representation from an advocate let alone a lawyer.
[From story] “And the deck is stacked against tenants in housing court. According to the New York County Lawyers Association, of the approximate 350,000 residential cases filed in housing court each year, only 11.9 percent of the tenant litigants had legal representation. The rest are pro se – forced to represent themselves. If they are lucky they will find a housing advocate like Coca to shepherd them through the process.”
Unfortunately, landlords are all too ready to evict New York tenants for frivolous and technical reasons because there is an economic incentive to do so. Landlords of rent stabilized apartments are eligible for a 20% vacancy increase every time a tenant leaves an apartment and the pressure to vacate can become unbearable for tenants in pads nearing the $2,000 de-control mark. As disgusting and horrible as landlord greed can be, housing court also plays a role in facilitating evictions and wholesale gentrification of neighborhoods. A certain judge’s attitude, demeanor and conduct towards tenants or the fact that housing court has become a giant debt collection agency and eviction mill contribute to making New York City less affordable and antagonistic to everyone not wealthy.
As to you letter lauding Judge Heymann’s conduct, do you think the senior citizen would have received the same treatment without an advocate? Chances are that the tenant would have had a difficult if not impossible time in a housing court with bullying landlord lawyers and yes, often unsympathetic judges.
I raise two important points in the article. One, Judge Heymann’s tardiness and two, Judge Jimenez’s alleged treatment of Yolanda Coca, a housing advocate. My point is that if Judge Heymann is tardy to court, what does that say to the tenants who show up on time? A little tardiness can be excused, though some lawyers and advocates (all wanted to remain unnamed) reported that Judge Heymann pushes the limit with his lateness.