Antiwar Dems Say Yes to Empire
All one needs to know about the Democrats’ position on Iraq is that they’ve caught the John Kerry disease: They’ll oppose the war before they vote to continue supporting it.
They oppose the war by calling on Bush to begin a phased withdrawal of troops. But both Democratic congressional bosses, Nancy Pelosi in the House and Harry Reid in the Senate, leave no doubt that the Democrats in fact support the war because they vowed to continue funding it.
In early January, Pelosi and Reid sent Bush a letter calling for an end to the war. They think Bush will heed a mere request the same week his administration asserted it can open U.S. mail without a warrant after Congress passed a law specifically prohibiting it from doing so.
If there’s a firm law in American politics it’s never to underestimate the stupidity or cowardice of the Democrats. The party leadership ran away from the Iraq War for most of last year. Then, realizing they could ride it to victory, they fell back on their sole strategy: “Anybody but Bush.”
From day one of their November victory they have been trying to subvert their mandate to end the war. In the last two months, leading Democrats, including Reid, Carl Levin in the Senate and Silvestre Reyes, the new House Intelligence Committee chair, have spoken in favor of Bush’s proposed escalation.
Sen. Joseph Biden said recently, “This is President Bush’s war.” That’s a big lie. Many Democrats voted for it in 2002 and have voted to fund it for the last four years. Biden is symptomatic of the Democrats’ attempt to dodge responsibility. The real reason for their spinelessness, the “support the troops” nonsense and not wanting to appear weak on national security aside, is that they will not challenge Empire.
There is a contradiction here. The realists – from the Iraq Study Group to John Murtha – want a strategic retreat from Iraq to save Empire. They want to refocus on the “war on terror” and broader interests in the strategic arc from North Africa to South Asia, rather than pissing away America’s military and economic power so Bush can keep acting squinty-eyed tough. But the realists will not confront the imperial presidency and its arrogation of powers to make war anywhere, anytime. So even though this war is against the interests of the elite, the politicians are unable to end it.
Reining in the state can happen only through a broad democratic grassroots surge. Given the failure of the antiwar movement to do much more than organize ritualistic marches (Cindy Sheehan’s persistence is one of the few bright spots), there is no real pressure to end the war.
Antiwar leaders suppressed protests during an election cycle once again in the hopes that the Democrats would deliver us from Iraq. If the antiwar movement is committed to ending the war it needs to act like it. The best route is by making the political lives of the Democrats hell. Only as a result of unrelenting pressure, protests, disruptions, occupations of their offices and more will the Democrats move as a party toward ending this debacle.
Absent that, the Iraq War will go on and will dominate another election two years from now where candidates talk of how much they oppose it even as they remain committed to supporting it.


You could have contributed to “making the political lives of the Democrats hell” in 2004 by supporting Nader and helping to build an independent left-wing alternative. Instead you suppoorted John “40,000 more troops” Kerry in knee-jerk Stalin style pop-front lesser evilism. Plan to join Leslie for more of the same in 2008?
What do you say about the President? There is a LARGE MAJORITY of people from across this country against his plan and yet he charges forward, immune, deaf and blind. I voted for Kerry in ’04 because I knew a vote for Nader was not a vote for “an independent left-wing alternative.” It was a vote for a good man and a tired choice for progressives. In this two party system (may it change some day), people who abhor the Iraq War and our criminal president, made a choice for John Kerry. Yes, it was anybody but Bush and it failed (if the election was stolen). The Dems have the power to stop the war, they were elected to do so. The ball is in their court.
The writer is needlessly attacking the Democrats, who aside from a couple anti-war rallies, are the only barrier against the Bush plan. The Dems. are rightly going to pass a resolution against the war and test the waters for broader action in Congress against the war. Dems. must take a cautious approach in cutting funding of the war to avoid damaging “selling out the troops” rhetoric that will/is coming from the White House. As a liberal, I hope this happens, but the timing must be right. It easy for those like the writer to take shots from the sidelines at the Dems. The Dems. were elected to take this war head on, but we must be thoughtful and smart about how we do it.
We didn’t, or I should say, I didn’t, support Kerry or Nader. Nuance often escapes the with-us-or-against-us mindset that infects the left. I wrote a piece in the Indy in mid-04 saying it would probably, objectively, be better if Kerry was elected but alsothat the left should DO NOTHING to help the Kerry campaign. The goal of the left, I argued, should be in building an independent movement that can, in part, be in a position to use pressure tactics against the political class, but that the real focus should be building movements that don’t adhere to the two-party system.
Supporting Nader in ’04 would have been pissing in the wind. In fact, it would have been no different than working for the Dems because his campaign had no traction and no support; it would have sucked a lot of organzing energy into a campaign that still supports the electoral process but one in which few people were willing to consider him. He received barely 10% of his 2000 vote count in ’04; it was obvious from the get-go, for anyone willing to think critically, that Nader was engaging in a pig-headed, egotistical, Kamikaze bid. You can’t argue what things should be; you have to understand how they are, and there was no base of support for Nader beyond the disgruntled left and protest votes. (I think one can make the argument that the Black community was alienated from both campaigns in ’04 and therefore there was an opening to gain mass support, but Nader, as he showed in 2000, was not willing to make the issues of Black America a central part of his campaign because he was too afraid of scaring off all the mushy white suburban liberals who supported him.)
And the way things are with the Dems is that they support empire. Blue Dog is Democratic ditto-head, unwilling to come to grips with reality. The fact is that the Dems are just as enthusiastic about war and imperialism as the right. They voted for the war in ’02; they’ve funded it almost without question for the last four years. Instead of pulling some ideas out of your ass that are in contradiction with the basic facts — “they are the only barrier against the Bush plan” — take a cold, hard look at the world as it actually is. Remember that Dems who want to end the Iraq War want to do so to save empire. Murtha’s plan is to re-focus on the war on terror and spread the troops around the Mideast to South Asia. They are the responsible imperialists.
Sure there are a few lone voices like Murtha and Kucinich who are willing to entertain using the power of the purse, but there is virtually no Dem in the Senate who is willing to do so. It’s not about “support the troops” rhethoric, that’s a cop-out. There is a two-year window to end the war before the next election. If the Dems used their power and ended the war now, no one would give a flying fuck in ’08 about about how much the right screamed “support the troops” because the WAR WOULD BE OVER.
They are unwilling to end the war because what they buy into is the notion that U.S. “strategic,” i.e., imperial, interests would be damaged in the Middle East if we withdrew. This is also idiotic, because the war has long been lost, all the U.S. is doing is delaying the inevitable defeat and ensuring that the eventual cost will be greater with each passing day.
This brings me back to the point in my article. The only way to end this war is through creative, militant mass-based organizing that refuses to do the bidding of either party or any party. It has to focus like a laser on the war and ending it while also recognizing ways to tie in issues of redistributive justice (beyond sloganeering like, “Money for jobs not for war”) that can motivate large groups of people.
The Democrats are not about to change, so when will the anti-war movement?
All of the leading lights of the Democratic Party have made it quite clear that they will never cut off funding to the war in Iraq (let alone to the “good” war in Afghanistan) or even considering impeaching Bush. Afterall, Democrats voted for every penny that Bush has asked for the past three years, long after all of Bush’s lies were exposed, not to mention the Patriot Act and every other piece of police-state legislation that the administration has put before them. On countless occasions they have all made it quite clear that they want to win the war every bit as much as Bush does. Only they, like many of the generals, see the GOP’s “neo-con” nut jobs as an obstacle to achieving that goal. Indeed, if it wasn’t for the open opposition of many of the Pentagon brass, expressed via long-time hawk John Murtha, amongst others, they wouldn’t even be pushing their meaningless resolutions in Congress. And if wasn’t for the efforts of the Iraqi resistance they wouldn’t even be doing that. Afrerall, what smart imperialist likes a losing war? And lest we forget, “redeployment” is a long way from the anti-war movement’s (and most of the country’s) position of immediate withdrawal. One more day, let alone, six more months of death and destruction is too high a price to pay for oil and empire.
But why should the Democrats act any differently? They are a capitalist party that upholds the interests of the empire abroad (as well as at home) and they are not about to give up control of the Middle East’s oil any more than the GOP is. Hence their staunch support of Israel, which has been US imperialism’s regional pit bull under both bosses parties. Check the Congressional Record and see how many “progressive” Democrats, never mind the heavyweights, opposed Israel’s war in Lebanon or, for that matter, have opposed Bush’s war mongering towards Iran and Syria.
So no matter how many well meaning anti-war activists take to the streets or to the halls of Congress to lobby them, the Democrats are not about to budge. And why should they? They know that no matter how pro-war they may be, the liberal left will support them anyway as the “lesser evil” in 2008 just as they did in 2004, when they backed a candidate who wanted to send twice as many troops as Bush is now doing. Or for that matter in 2006, when they stayed off the streets (including and especially during the war in Lebanon) in order to take back Congress, voting for pro-war politicians like Hillary Clinton and Ned Lamont instead of real anti-war candidates like Howie Hawkins or Todd Cretian. As long as no viable left alternative that threatens their stranglehold over the masses of working people exists, the Democrats will continue to take the liberal left’s support for granted and go on supporting the war, Israel, “globalization,” etc. And that will continue for as long as the reformist lesser-evilists, who believe that any social change in this country, on any issue, has to come from within the Democratic party, are allowed to dominate what passes for a left in this country. So, by all means hit the streets on January 27 and March 17 but connect the movement against the war to a fight to build an independent working-class alternative to both bosses’ parties. One Eugene V. Debs or Karl Leibnecht (or Howie Hawkins or Todd Cretian) in the halls of congress who gets up and says not one dime, not one man or woman for the imperialist war is worth more than all the progressive Democrats, who, when all is said and done, will follow Hillary Clinton and Barak Obama in following George Bush.
Enough far left wing yapping. Let’s live in the U.S. of today. There are two ways this war will stop. The best bet is backing the not perfect Democrats who have passed a resolution against the war and are in a position to pressure the President. Just because Pelosi says they won’t cut the purse strings to the war doesn’t mean that they won’t. That is where good old fashion pressure politics from liberals and progressives comes in. That is why marches, lobbying and writing your elected officials is important. Roy Rollin, Eugene Debs has been dead for quite some time and nobody knows who the hell the other two people you mentioned are. That is laughable. Atleast AK was insightful.
My point is, there will be no third party anytime soon that has any real power. So what are anti-war proponents to do? Support the only oppositional party with any power (the Democrats) or completely abandon electoral politics and lobbying and pressure tactics? That will be a disaster for this country and the war will drag on.
Just to throw fuel on the fire….Yeah, I’ll vote for who ever the Democrats put on the damn ticket against this President or who ever else the Republicans pick!
So the Democrats are going to pressure the president; into what, …better ways of winning the war? Some oppositional party…they vote over and over again to continue funding the war and say beforehand that they will continue to do so. What country are you living in? Yeah, you’ll vote for any Democrat they pick… exactly why they take your vote for granted. Break with the Democrats or get broken by them, although you obviously already have been.
Blue State–why don’t offer something more substantial other than invective and baseless assertions? The comment about “not perfect Democrats” is a fallacy. No one is asking them to be perfect. RR offered a concrete analysis of where the real power interests lie, to which your response barely rises above the level of “I know you are but what am I?”
There are real institutional interests that shape the political class. That is the real world. To understand why the Democrats are not doing anything more than offering meaningless resolutions requires a critical analysis of those interests. It’s no secret. Almost every Democrat in Congress is beholden to big money through the coporations and wealthy that fund their campaigns. The few that aren’t are rich enough to fund their interests themselves.
Go back to the point I made: “the realists will not confront the imperial presidency and its arrogation of powers to make war anywhere, anytime. So even though this war is against the interests of the elite, the politicians are unable to end it.”
Why won’t they confront the imperial presidency? Because despite the blunders of Vietnam and now Iraq it works well for the economic elite. Having power centered in one narrow institution headed by one powerful individual allows the state to quickly deploy power in the interests of the elite. Having foreign policy and war-making decided by hundreds of voices in Congress, which is what is supposed to happen, is messy and time-consuming and far less likely to result in action. Of course this would be great for the majority of Americans and even moreso the world, but it doesn’t serve the interests of Empire.
Take a look at history, it has only been those movements willing to confront power with power that made real change happen. Do you think the Vietnam War ended because of some marches, letter writing and pleading with elected representatives? It ended because of the civilian and military antiwar movements that revolted against the state and made the war too difficult to continue.
Well, actually, the Vietnam war ended because the Vietnameese made the Americans cry uncle by killing too many of them for Americans to stomach. But other than that, AK is mostly right.