Menu
Seneca Lake Protesters.jpg

Charges Dismissed for 42 Seneca Lake Gas Storage Protesters

We Are Seneca Lake Mar 23

Watkins Glen, NY – In three speedy hearings on Wednesday night in the Town of Reading court, Judge Raymond Berry granted a motion to dismiss all charges “in the interests of justice” brought by 42 Seneca Lake protesters. All had been arrested as part of a sustained civil disobedience campaign at the gates of Crestwood Midstream.

The campaign, We Are Seneca Lake, opposes the expansion of gas storage in abandoned lakeside salt caverns owned by Crestwood. 

Further, attorneys for the defendants announced that an agreement had been reached with the Schuyler County district attorney’s office to accept identical dismissal motions from the roughly 100 other civil disobedients also charged with trespassing and disorderly conduct relating to protests at Seneca Lake and whose cases are still pending. At least 20 cases have been transferred to other area courts in Schuyler County.

Ithaca attorney Ray Schlather, member of the legal defense team advising the protesters, negotiated the mass dismissal agreement.

Individually and in groups, the defendants who appeared before Judge Berry on Wednesday night submitted an oral motion asking for dismissal of their charges. They read from a statement that said,  

We only have this planet. We must safeguard it for those who follow. Would that it not be necessary, but sometimes citizens of good conscience must engage in non-violent acts of civil disobedience to protect that sacred trust. As long as Crestwood Midstream Partners, or any other corporate or public or private entity, continues to threaten our way of life by the proven dangerous storage of highly compressed gas in the crumbling caverns at the Salt Point facility, I reserve the right to act as my conscience dictates in order to protect Seneca Lake, its citizens, and the surrounding environment. I reserve all rights to protest further at the Crestwood facility, although it is not my intent at this time to break the law in doing so.

After each recitation, assistant district attorney John Tunney expressed his willingness to accept a motion to dismiss. In each case, Judge Berry granted the motion and dismissed the charges “with prejudice.”

The proceedings were remarkable for the commendation offered to the protesters by Judge Berry, who has not always been fulsome in his praise for their actions during the five-month-long campaign that has seen maximum fines and jail sentences.

To one group of defendants, Berry said, “I’m very proud of you. You had a cause and you fought for it to the best of your ability. Congratulations.” 

To another, he said, “I’ve grown to admire you people.”

Defense attorney, Sujata Gibson, who has worked closely with protesters since December, said, “This is a big moment in history to have this many cases dismissed in the interests of justice. It affirms the importance of this cause and the ethical motivations of the protesters. I’m sure the court and district attorney’s office were in a very difficult position, and they should be applauded for the thought they put into looking for outcomes that promote justice.”

Gibson continued, “We’ve seen a sea change in the way the court and the prosecutors have reacted to our cases—from maximum sentences for jail terms for trespassing violations to large-scale offers to support dismissals in the interests of justice. This is a testament to the sincerity and passion of the protesters. They are single mothers, wine makers, business owners and teachers. Their stories are deeply affecting. I’ve watched Judge Berry and the D.A. become very moved by the willingness of these human beings to make enormous sacrifices. I myself have been deeply moved.”

Protester Michael Dineen, who had previously been sentenced to jail by Berry for a protest-related act of trespassing and had a similar charge dismissed on Wednesday, said, “I am extremely proud to be part of a community that is willing to be arrested in such numbers to prevent Crestwood’s plan to industrialize our region and threaten our lake. And I’m thankful that the Schuyler County DA's office has recognized that ‘we all have an obligation to protect our environment,’ and that justice is therefore best served by dismissing all charges.”

Protesters whose charges were dismissed last night were:

Judy Abrams, 66, Trumansburg, Tompkins County

Edgar Brown, 60, Naples, Ontario County

Carolyn Byrne, 38, Ithaca, Tompkins County

Deborah Cippola-Dennis, 49, Dryden, Tompkins County

Joanne Cippola-Dennis, 53, Dryden, Tompkins County

Lyndsay Clark, 53, Springwater, Livingston County

James Connor, 83, Mecklenburg, Schuyler County

Doug Couchon, 64, Elmira, Chemung County

Kim Cunningham, 58, Naples, Ontario County

John Dennis, 63, Lansing, Tompkins County

Michael Dineen, 65, Ovid, Seneca County

Peter Drobney, 56, Corning, Steuben County

Martha Ferger, 90, Dryden, Tompkins County

Richard Figiel, 68, Hector, Schuyler County

Carrie Fischer, 38 Fayette, Seneca County

Kenneth Fogarty, 75, Guilford, Chenango County

Lynn Gerry, 58, Watkins Glen, Schuyler County

Heather Hallagan, 41, Meckenburg, Schuyler County

Carey Harben, 47, Hector, Schuyler County

Nancy Kasper, 56, North Rose, Wayne County

Sharon Kahkonen, 65, Mecklenburg, Schuyler County

Crow Marley, 55, Hector, Schuyler County

Faith Meckley, 20, Geneva, Ontario County

Kelly Morris, 55, Danby, Tompkins County

Paul Passavant, 48, Geneva, Ontario County

Kirsten Pierce, 44, Burdett, Schuyler County

Mariah Plumlee, 35, Covert, Seneca County

Leslie Potter, 70, Big Flats, Chemung County

Dan Rapaport, 54, Newfield, Tompkins County

Stephanie Redmond, 38, Ithaca, Tompkins County

Rick Rogers, 66, Spencer, Tioga County

Cat Rossiter, 62, Sayre, Bradford County, PA

Laura Salamendra, 30, Geneva, Ontario County

Coby Schultz, 54, Springwater, Livingston County

Elan Shapiro, 67, Ithaca, Tompkins County

Brion Seime, 42, Newfield, Tompkins County

Stefan Senders, 55, Hector, Schuyler County

Audrey Southern, 31, Burdett, Schuyler County

Chris Tate, 52, Hector, Schuyler County

John Wertis, 51, Wertis, Trumansburg, Tompkins County

Dwain Wilder, 75, Rochester, Monroe County

Ruth Young, 77, Horseheads, Chemung County

______________________________

RELATED COVERAGE

"Flood Wall Street 10 Found Not Guilty"  by Indypendent Staff

"New York's Fracking Battles Heat Up" by Patrick Robbins

"New Yorkers Urge Cuomo to Veto Port Ambrose LNG Terminal" by Alex Ellefson

"We Are Next: California Looks to Follow New York's Fracking Ban" by Jimmy Tobias

"Small Town, Big Fracking Victory" by John Tarleton

"In Defense of Their Land and Water: A Photo Essay" by Michael Premo and Andrew Stern

"Romanian Rendevous" by Jim Wickens

People's Climate March Special Issue (Sept. 2014)

The Indypendent is a monthly New York City-based newspaper and website To subscribe to our print edition, click here. To make a donation or to become a monthly sustainer, click here.

 

Comments are closed.