The Media and the NYC Mayoral Race
In contrast to the 2021 mayoral contest, the Post and The Times are mostly sitting out this year’s Democratic primary.
For Part 2 of this series, see “Lesser Known Media Outlets Vie to Make Their Voices Heard in NYC Mayoral Race” by Theodore Hamm.
Four years ago, a mid-April opinion poll found that only 24% of likely voters in the 2021 primary intended to rank Eric Adams first or second, placing him well behind frontrunner Andrew Yang’s 38%. Kathryn Garcia tallied only 13% in the top two slots, and just two months before voting commenced, she had very low name recognition.
The late June results, of course, showed that Adams finished first or second on 61% of ballots, with Garcia reaching nearly 40%. The latter’s strength in later rounds of the ranked-choice voting process enabled her to ultimately finish only one percentage point behind Adams.
There is little doubt that the crime-obsessed New York Post helped drive Adams’ surge, while the enthusiastic backing of The New York Times made technocrat Garcia a viable challenger. It appears quite unlikely that history will repeat itself in this year’s primary.
Current Democratic frontrunner Andrew Cuomo has been getting no love whatsoever from the Post. An early March editorial called him the “Biggest Liar in New York,” warning readers that the disgraced former governor may “grope you.” Later in the month, a second editorial as well as a cover story spotlighted Cuomo’s nursing home scandal. Another cover featured his alleged affair with his then-married hatchet woman.
The Post has been so relentless in trashing Cuomo that the candidate reportedly has been seeking a meeting with Rupert Murdoch, the tabloid’s 94-year-old figurehead.
The Post has been so relentless in trashing Cuomo that the candidate reportedly has been seeking a meeting with Rupert Murdoch, the tabloid’s 94-year-old figurehead. If given the opportunity, Cuomo would surely remind Murdoch that he’s been a longtime friend of the 1%.
As of mid-April, it’s not clear if the Post will back any candidate in the Democratic primary. But it will continue to spew bile at the insurgent democratic socialist challenger Zohran Mamdani. In addition to relentless accusations regarding Mamdani’s supposed antisemitism, a recent hit piece called the candidate’s plan for free buses “something out of the Politburo.” Voters alive when the Soviet Union existed may grasp the reference to the Communist Party’s directorate. Meanwhile, many of the Post’s most fervent readers will continue to enjoy riding the ferry back and forth to Staten Island for — you guessed it — free.
As of now, the Post appears to be saving its powder for the general election, which likely will include Mayor Adams on an independent line and Curtis Sliwa as the Republican nominee. There will be candidates running on the Democratic as well as Working Families Party lines. Others may enter the fray. Alas, the Post will continue to flex its muscles.
• • •
Last summer, The Times announced that it would no longer make endorsements in local races. In the outlet’s own story about the decision, The Times’ opinion editor provided no explanation about the decision. As mentioned, the editorial board’s backing of Garcia nearly made her the mayor. Meanwhile, Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg successfully capitalized on The Times’ support in a hotly contested 2021 race.
There has been a steady decline in the local coverage found in the “paper of record” in recent years. Once the home of influential commentators including Michael Powell, Jim Dwyer and Bob Herbert, The Times is now down to one local columnist, Ginia Bellafante, who writes a weekend entry. In general, the publication is now a “lifestyle” brand, and the grit and grime of New York City politics isn’t of much interest in Montclair.
Although she is not a declared candidate for mayor, NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch clearly would get plenty of favorable coverage in The Times if she entered the race. Since taking the reins as the fourth NYPD boss in Eric Adams’ first term late last year, Tisch has already received a steady stream of flattering profiles. That her 1% lineage explains such attention is not even something The Times attempts to deny, with a recent headline referring to Tisch as an “heiress.”
If Tisch indeed ends up on the November ballot, The Times and the Post likely would find common ground. The Post recently commended Tisch’s “sterling record of successful public service.” In 1%-speak, that means “she’s ours.”
Coming up next from Theodore Hamm: Which media outlets might exert more sway in the June primary?





