The Latest Developer Scam: City Charter Revisions That Claim to “Fast-Track Affordable Housing”
Three of the six ballot questions (numbers 2-4) that New York City voters are facing are falsely advertised as promoting “affordable housing.” They are instead the most recent scams that substantially reduce the ability of community boards and City Council members to influence big developer schemes that, in the end, are more likely to increase rents and house prices and fuel gentrification and displacement in their neighborhoods.
The changes to the City Charter follow the long history of fueling developer-driven growth that tends to jack up rents and housing prices and displace existing residents. It follows the previous Eric Adams scam known as “The City of Yes,” which targeted lower- and medium-density neighborhoods that have opposed big development schemes that raise rents and home prices while failing to protect and instead displace many tenants and homeowners. Adams took his cue from the developer-backed YIMBY (Yes-In-My-Backyard) critics, which white-washed community opposition to giant zoning changes that fueled increases in land values and rents. Those pushing back on developer proposals were disproportionately Black, Brown and Asian working class renters and homeowners but they also included many working class whites. Yet they have been dismissed by the pro-developer advocates as racist, stubborn romantics or just plain self-interested.
These ballot initiatives are a continuation of housing and land use policies that have for over a century been based on the myth that building more housing units is the key to “solving” the shortage of affordable housing. However, stacking up more housing units around the city has invariably jacked up land prices, which in turn increased rents and housing costs and further fed the displacement of existing low-income and working class tenants and homeowners. It completely evades the need to preserve and expand existing affordable housing units – in public housing, Mitchell-Lama and low- and middle-income cooperatives, and low- and middle-income working class homeowners who face predatory investors, deed theft and speculators anxious to clear out more space for more profitable new development (albeit with some token “affordable” housing).
The City Charter changes do nothing to address these issues.
Instead they help to silence the voices of all who dare to stand in the way of developer-driven deregulation. Worse, they help cement the investors’ hold on New York City’s housing and zoning policies and further demonize community opposition. Under the current system for land use approval, organized community pressure can force developers to come to the table and offer more affordable housing and other community benefits lest City Council vote down a project that doesn’t garner the support of the councilmember in the affected district. Of course, not all opposition is good, but silencing opposition cannot be the answer in a socially-progressive administration.
All of us who support Zoran Mamdani for mayor need to ask hard questions of our candidate, who has boldly stood up for tenant rights and alternative approaches that can protect working class tenants and homeowners while expanding what many call “social housing” – that is, policies driven by social need and not developer greed. Will he take hold of and truly reform the government apparatus that has historically made this “The Real Estate Capital of the World,” to borrow from the Bloomberg-era slogan? Can he help empower Black, Brown and new immigrant communities and help them become protagonists of a more just city? Can he respect and strengthen the voices of the many neighborhoods that form his base? The proposed Charter changes are but the latest attempts to strengthen the imperial mayor, weaken the increasingly democratic City Council, and blame communities and community boards for a housing regime that they did not create and currently have little control over.
Tom Angotti is Professor Emeritus of Urban Planning at CUNY and an advocate of housing justice. He is author of New York for Sale and co-editor of Zoned Out, two books about housing and community-based planning in New York City.
The Indypendent is reader-funded. We publish a free monthly newspaper, a website, a weekly radio show on WBAI-99.5 FM and more. To make a one-time or recurring monthly donation, click here.





