Menu

Hakeem Jeffries Was One of the Biggest Losers in New York’s Democratic Primary Blowout

New York City DSA’s’ landslide victories last night make the House’s top Democrat an inviting target for 2028.

Theodore Hamm Jun 24

In the run-up to the June 23 primary, Hakeem Jeffries picked his battles — and lost all of them. 

The top Democrat in the House made a strong push for Adriano Espaillat but did not wage a similar effort for incumbent Dan Goldman. Although Antonio Reynoso aligned himself with Jeffries, the party leader did not return the support. 

In a state Assembly race in a district that overlaps with the Central Brooklyn portion of Jeffries’ House terrain, DSA-backed Eon Huntley joined fellow socialists Darializa Avila Chevalier and Claire Valdez (and progressive Brad Lander) in the winners’ circle. A strong plug from the national Democratic leader did little to boost incumbent Assemblymember Stefani Zinerman, who finished over 20 points behind Huntley.

“The roof is collapsing on the Democratic Party establishment,” anti-left analyst Van Jones insisted on CNN. In his view, the “insurgency” led by both Mayor Mamdani and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio Cortez is “both a movement and a machine at the same time.” While Mamdani campaigned hard for both Valdez and Avila Chevalier, AOC sat out both races, leaving little doubt about who is the New York City left’s leader at the moment.  

The NYC-DSA’s voter-mobilization operation is indeed proving to be a well-oiled machine. Antonio Reynoso’s 21-point loss is a clear sign that the socialist left — rather than the Working Families Party and its entourage of progressive unions — now controls certain areas of the city. 

In a recent podcast, NYC-DSA co-chair Grace Mausser told host Ben Max that after opting not to back a proposed challenge by Chi Ossé to Jeffries in this year’s primary, the group is now “surrounding him” with their elected officials, aiming to “exert pressure” on the national party leader to move leftward. Jeffries, a stalwart AIPAC ally, is most unlikely to do so on Israel-Palestine. Will the veteran corporate Democrat now call for the expansion of social spending? 

U.S. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, the Democratic leader in the U.S. House of Representatives

In a lengthy May profile in the New Yorker, Jeffries assured reporter Jason Zengerle that if the Democrats gain control of the House after the midterm elections, “Our focus will be to deliver on our promise to make life more affordable for the American people.  We’re going to aggressively move forward with a legislative agenda that is designed to bring down the cost of a house, bring down the cost of health care, and bring down the cost of groceries, along with utility bills and child care.” 

Earlier this month, the deliberative Democratic boss created five “cost of living” working groups that will put forward specific proposals. That AOC was named co-chair of the health care committee may suggest some newfound interest from the leadership in Medicare for All — but Jeffries also appointed Alabama’s Terri Sewell, a proponent of strengthening the current health care system, as co-chair. 

The current vagueness of the national party’s agenda hardly inspired voters to turn out in the primary. Meanwhile, the platforms of both Avila Chevalier and Valdez called for vast expansions of the social safety net, with the former calling for beefing up Social Security and the latter proposing universal rent control. Such measures are not what the party’s Wall Street donors want. 

Despite his newfound alliance with AOC, Jeffries also remains a DSA antagonist. Along with allies granted anonymity to hurl insults at socialists in the New Yorker profile, the party leader lobbed his own grenades, at one point claiming that the DSA disdains public housing residents. 

“Chi would have won,” NYC-DSA co-chair Gustavo Gordillo tweeted soon after the polls closed on June 23, referring to the primary challenge that did not happen. It’s hard to imagine that Jeffries would not agree (at least in private). The ball is now in his court.

Ted Hamm’s Meet Mayor Mamdani is available from OR Books. Use coupon Indy15 at checkout for 15% off (valid through June 30).