Columbia’s Cooperation With ICE Calls Back to KKK Days
During the 1920s KKK resurgence, Columbia swept anti-Black persecution under the rug
On February 26, ICE agents abducted Elmina Aghayeva from her Columbia University dormitory. “Elle,” a senior undergraduate, was an Azerbaijani national with an expired student visa. That afternoon, a protest gathered at Columbia’s main gate, decrying the kidnapping, reiterating demands made over the past year that the university serve as a sanctuary campus, and breaking into the familiar chant of “No ICE, no KKK, no fascist USA!” The slogan fit the scene even better than most of the gathering (presumably) knew: Aghayeva’s kidnapping, committed in some degree of coordination with the university’s private security (a university officer accompanied the ICE agents), echoed events at Columbia a century ago, with ICE playing the role of the Ku Klux Klan.
In the early 1920s, the institution tacitly allowed a Klan chapter to form on campus, resulting in the hate group menacing a Black student, Frederick Wells. They burned a cross on the quad and broke into Furnald Hall in an attempt to attack Wells in his room.
The 1920s KKK was a resurgent organization. While anti-Black racism was woven into the Klan’s very existence, the 1920s Klan added new targets. It campaigned against Catholics and Jews—groups that the KKK held as both racially inferior and a threat to American values—and it took a hardline stance against immigration from anywhere that was not considered “Nordic.”
A mainstream organization, the KKK influenced electoral politics, helping to elect 12 state governors, and federal immigration policy, contributing to the severe immigration restrictions introduced in 1921 and 1924. By some accounts more powerful in cities than outside of them, the Klan made serious inroads in the Northeast and set its sights on New York City as a potential stronghold. By 1923, there were claims of 34,000 members spread among 21 functioning “klaverns” in the city, according to Kenneth Jackson, author of The Ku Klux Klan in the City, 1915–1930.
For KKK Imperial Wizard William Joseph Simmons, NYC was the “most un-American of all cities,” and Columbia was “least American of all schools.” Nonetheless, and perhaps ironically, Columbia became the Klan’s NYC entry point. Many would have found this unsurprising; Langston Hughes, for one, had experienced Columbia’s culture of racism, its southern clubs and Blackface parties, where Black and Asian students were routinely challenged regarding their credentials. Columbia had recently started imposing unspoken quotas, effectively cutting its Jewish student population in half, between 1920 and 1930—and particularly restricting working-class Jewish immigrants and first-generation citizens of NYC.
In the early 1920s, the institution tacitly allowed a Klan chapter to form on campus, resulting in the hate group menacing a Black student, Frederick Wells.
In 1923, word of a student “klavern” at Columbia began to circulate. At the university’s 1923 graduation, a Klan-robed coterie processed through the ceremony grounds, weaving through crowds of students and their families, some of whom cheered them on. If the demonstration was a case of the KKK testing the Columbia waters, the group found smooth sailing.
On April 2, 1924, fresh snow blanketed the streets of NYC. As midnight approached, the stately gray structures and manicured green lawns of Columbia University were whitened, muted. The sound of automotive engines tore through the quiet, cars roaring through the gates at 116th Street and braking to a stop on the 116th Street walkway. Out of the vehicles poured about 20 figures, pulling on white robes and hoods, and pulling out of one car a seven-foot wooden cross, hoisting it onto their shoulders, the Brooklyn Standard Union reported. They ran to the campus’s South Field, pushed the cross upright, and set it afire, in full view of the dormitories lining the quad. Most importantly, for their aims, the cross was visible from Furnald Hall, the dormitory that housed their target, Wells, a Black law student. The Klansmen danced around the burning cross for a few minutes before charging into Furnald, storming through the halls shouting, “Put the n-word out!” as Wells barred his door and prepared for an assault, relieved when it did not come.
The raid could have been foreseen. Wells, 25, a Harlem resident originally from Union City, Tennessee, had enrolled in Columbia for the 1924 spring term. In March he moved into Furnald, becoming the only Black resident among almost entirely white graduate students; there were one or two Asian students. Most of Wells’s dorm-mates, seeing him around the building, assumed he was a janitor or courier.
When they figured out he lived among them, a group led by law student J. B. Rucker, native of North Carolina, went to Dean Herbert Hawkes, demanding Wells’s removal. Hawkes rejected them, so Rucker took his objections to the newspapers, impugning Wells and his alleged frequent guests as badly behaved. The ensuing Daily News investigation, while finding support for Wells among some students—”I prefer living with him than with several other fellows in the building,” said one—refers to Rucker and his crew, vaguely, as “what were called the Ku Klux Klan, irate young southerners and others.” The Klan offensive came soon after.
On April 3, as the Columbia community reckoned with the incident, gawking at the charred remains of the blackened cross against the white snow, Wells received two letters signed by the Klan. The first, slipped under his door, contained a death threat, the New York Age reported, while the second offered Wells “free advice” that he leave the dorm, so that it could be a place for whites again. The letter also acknowledges and complains of the presence of Jewish students: “for as you perhaps know, the Jewish race is of colored extraction, which explains why you have their support.”
Hawkes quickly conducted an investigation and almost as quickly exonerated all students, placing blame on outside agitators, while rumors abounded that Rucker and his ilk had called upon a KKK chapter in New Jersey to carry out the attack. Some white students of the dorm, meanwhile, told the press that the whole affair was a false flag, that Wells’s friends had donned the grab and burned the cross to garner public sympathy for him.
Wells, defiantly proclaimed, “I’m here to stay.” But Wells was actually not. He finished the semester at Columbia and transferred to Cornell that summer. Columbia, after sweeping the incident under the rug, decided, in 1925, to preclude further problems by ending its brief experiment with unsegregated housing: Black students would no longer be permitted in its dormitories.
Jonathan Ezra Goldman is a Humanities professor at New York Institute of Technology. He is the author of Hidden Histories of Jazz Age New York: From the Suppressed to the Strange.
The Indypendent is a New York City-based newspaper, website and weekly radio show. All of our work is made possible by readers like you. Please consider making a recurring or one-time donation today or subscribe to our monthly print edition and get every copy sent straight to your home.




