Menu

End of the American Empire?

Issue 302

The US-Israel war on Iran is an epic disaster in the making.

John Tarleton Mar 25

Bombs rained down on Iran like falling stars. In the shaky video, men climbed on rubble to dig out survivors. They carried limp, dust coated children’s bodies. Sometimes just pieces. In the opening hours of their war on Iran, the U.S. and Israel launched strikes that killed 168 schoolgirls, Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamanei and dozens of the country’s top military leaders. Donald Trump quickly proclaimed victory. “We won,” he said 

 Nothing could be further from the truth. 

The Iranians are routinely hitting U.S. military bases, the Persian Gulf states that host them and Israel with missiles and drones. Thousands of U.S. Marines are being shipped out for a potential ground invasion targeting the Strait of Hormuz. And, the Pentagon is seeking $200 billion in additional funding to prosecute this war. The US is not winning, but the world is losing. 

As in early 2020, we are on the precipice of a global crisis that could upend our lives in ways that seem unimaginable until they happen. This time the deadly virus is the unchecked militarism of the US and Israel which led them to start a war they were confident they could win within two or three days.  

Where do things go from here? 

On March 20, Trump mused that he was about ready to wind down the conflict and once again declare victory. It’s classic Trump. Create a giant mess and walk away from it without facing any consequences. Maybe his luck will hold up once more.

However, Iran’s leaders have repeatedly emphasized they are no longer interested in temporary ceasefires that give the US and Israel time to regroup and attack again. Instead, the Iranians insist they can ride out the horrors of the U.S.-Israeli bombing campaign and use their newly won hammerlock over roughly 20 percent of the world’s oil supply to extract the kind of concessions—sanctions relief, reparations, withdrawal of U.S. military bases from the Persian Gulf region—that the U.S. is currently loathe to even consider. 

A Military Solution?

When you drive, you use oil. When you drink from a plastic cup, you use oil. When you put on make-up or clothing, you use oil. Almost every second of our lives is based on oil being shipped, processed and pumped. Now that is all teetering on the edge of collapse. 

Before the war, 20 percent of the world’s oil supply and 30 percent of natural gas was shipped out of the Persian Gulf and through the narrow Strait of Hormuz which abuts Iran. Going back decades, American presidents of both parties have rejected Israeli entreaties to join in a war against Iran. They understood that it could lead to an Iranian takeover of the Strait and judged the risk not to be worth the reward. In the vainglorious Trump and his inner circle of sycophants and yes men, the Israelis finally found their willing marks. 

Almost every second of our lives is based on oil being shipped, processed and pumped. Now that is all teetering on the edge of collapse. 

Now, as long predicted, the Iranian have taken over the Strait and are dictating which ships can come and go. Regaining control of the Strait will be a bloody fight with a high chance of failure. The Iranians are dug in along a mountainous coastline. The waters of the Strait are likely laden with mines. Moreover, the leading edge of modern warfare—aerial bombardment via precision-guided missiles and cheap, easy to mass produce swarms of killer drones—favors the Iranians. This is why four weeks into the conflict, the powerful U.S. Navy has been unwilling to escort stranded oil tankers through the Strait. If U.S. troops are able to wrest control of the Iranian coastline along the Strait, or seize Kharg Island, the eight-square mile coral reef where 90 percent of Iran’s oil and gas exports are shipped from, they will still be sitting ducks . 

This kind of warfare has been on display for the past four years in the Russo-Ukraine War. It’s why the two sides in that war have been locked in World War I-style trench warfare. Any visible target can be swiftly eliminated. The US has poured $70 billion in military aid into Ukraine, according to the Council on Foreign Relations. But only the Iranians, who have supplied the Russians with their Shahed drones, seemed to have learned anything from that conflict. 

Iran’s asymmetrical advantages also extend to its ability to strike the US’s Persian Gulf allies, US military bases in the region and even Israel whose Iron Dome missile defense system is proving to be more porous than previously thought. While an Iranian drone costs $20,000-$30,000 to build, each US missile interceptor costs upwards of $1,000,000 and takes longer to produce. Over time, the math favors the Iranians who have already scored a number of direct hits on U.S. early warning radar sites in the region and subsequently seen their hit rates go up. 

The Iranians control the escalation ladder. Trump can threaten to obliterate their energy infrastructure, but the Iranians can credibly respond to do the same to America’s Gulf state allies and go one step further and threaten their water desalination plants, something those desert-based countries will implore Trump to not let happen. 

If the US-Israeli war effort continues to falter, there is one rung on the escalation ladder that they can reach for that the Iranians cannot—nuclear weapons. The taboo against using nukes has been observed for more than eight decades since the US dropped two atomic bombs on Japan in August 1945 at the end of World War II. Releasing the nuclear genie from the bottle is something no sane person wants to see happen. But, we’re talking about Netanyahu, who leads a nation that just gleefully committed a genocide in Gaza, and Trump, a violent, impulsive man who thrills at violating established norms and standards. If nuclear weapons were deployed, they would likely be described as “limited” or “low yield” to try and mollify public opinion. No one should buy it. 

Economic Warfare

While favorable geography and low-cost advances in modern warfare have given Iran the upper hand militarily in ways the US did not anticipate, its real power in this moment lies in its ability to inflict economic pain on the US and its allies. The soaring price of gas gets the headlines. Most Americans rely on their cars to get around—aren’t you glad you live in New York City?—and no amount of Trump administration spin can change what they see when they fill up their tank. If the Iranians achieve their goal of driving the price of a barrel of oil up to $200, the price per gallon at the pump could hit $7, $8 or even $10 per gallon. 

But, that’s only the beginning. Higher gas prices, especially diesel, mean higher transport costs for everything you buy. Persian Gulf oil and gas is also the foundation for many supply chains. 

One third of all fertilizer comes from that region. Rich countries can pay the higher price and pass the expense onto unhappy consumers. In much of the Global South, it will mean dramatically lower crop yields, increased hunger and the political turmoil that follows. 

Helium is an indispensable element in the production of semiconductors. South Korea and Taiwan are especially dependent on helium produced in Qatar which is home to the world’s largest natural gas reserves. “Shortages of helium and energy in South Korea will cascade across the entire tech economy,” writes Forbes. “Samsung and SK Hynix dominate memory chips—they produce more than half of the world’s supply. The memory is needed for everything from cell phones to automobiles. So expect prices to climb as shortages start to ripple through supply chains.”

Faced with rising prices, the Federal Reserve will jack up interest rates even if it throws the economy into a recession (or worse) in order to choke off inflation. The oil shock of the 1970s caused a decade of “stagflation” i.e. high inflation and high rates of unemployment at the same time. We are headed in a similar direction at a time when our social safety has been shredded to pay for lavish tax cuts for the rich and supercharged spending for ICE and the military. This is not politically sustainable. The struggle to ensure Trump doesn’t sabotage the midterms and finish consolidating an authoritarian state will be paramount.

Long-Term Impacts

The United States emerged from World War II as the world’s most powerful nation and it led the way in establishing a series of global institutions—the United Nations, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank among others—and a web of regional military alliances that spanned the globe. Pax Americana, like Pax Romana 2,000 years before, helped expand international trade and commerce much to its own benefit. It also has been ruthless in its willingness to crush revolts on the imperial periphery. But whatever stability the US once provided, the mask is now off. It is raw, brutal and ugly. 

The Iran War will be disastrous for U.S. allies in Asia like  South Korea and Taiwan who rely heavily on Persian Gulf oil and gas. They are also watching with dismay as the US withdraws high tech missile defense systems intended to deter North Korea and China in order to replenish depleted stocks in the Persian Gulf. 

Whatever stability the US once provided, the mask is now off. It is raw, brutal and ugly. 

Many of our European allies also rely on Persian Gulf oil and gas and will pay a high price for this war. It’s also beginning to dawn on the Europeans that if Israel succeeds in its quest to turn Iran (population 92 million) into a failed state like Iraq, Syria and Libya, they could be facing a migration crisis that will dwarf the one that occurred a decade ago at the height of the Syrian Civil War. 

The war that has already been won is wrecking the Persian Gulf monarchies (Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, Oman and the United Arab Emirates) whose oil and gas exports are being throttled by Iran. Since the oil boom of the 1970s, the Gulf states have priced and sold their oil in U.S. dollars in return for U.S. security guarantees. Because oil is the world’s most traded commodity, this helps cement the dollar’s role as the international currency. These wealthy petrostates then reinvest their profits into U.S. Treasury bills and other financial assets, making it easier for the US to run large budget deficits. If they see the US can’t protect them and dump the dollar, it will be a powerful blow to the US’s dollar hegemony. It would also further drive up the interest rates the U.S. government has to pay to finance its deficits. 

At least two countries stand to benefit greatly from this war. 

Russia, one of the world’s largest oil and gas producers, has been heavily sanctioned since its 2022 invasion of Ukraine and has had to sell at heavily discounted prices to countries like China and India. Those sanctions have been lifted for now. The Russians are once again free to sell on international markets and for a premium rate no less with prices soaring. This will help them replenish their war machine to the dismay of Ukraine and its supporters who see it as a democratic bulwark holding the line against the spread of autocracy. In an additional irony, the Russians are profiteering off the war even as it is widely suspected they are providing the Iranians with advanced satellite data to improve the accuracy of their missile strikes. 

Soaring oil and gas prices are going to accelerate the growth of renewable energy production and electric cars around the world. And no country is better prepared to take advantage of that than China. It currently manufactures more than 80 percent of solar panels according to the International Energy Agency, and over 70 percent of new electric cars.

“The sooner you go EV,” writes American Prospect’s Ryan Cooper, “the sooner you can be free from the oil price gyrations caused by yet another deranged Republican war in the Middle East.”

While the Chinese seize the high ground of a green energy future, they can look on as their main global rival bogs down in another Middle Eastern forever war. Of course, the US could prosper from these same trends if Trump hadn’t taken a sledgehammer to the wind and solar industries and bullied U.S. automakers into shelving new investments in electric vehicles which the Biden administration had strongly backed. 

“The  plans to have an all-electric future by the middle of next decade have definitely been put on hold,” notes CNN’s Chris Isidore who covers the auto industry. 

Here in New York, Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul is showing a similar lack of imagination. While Hochul has been approving natural gas pipelines that she previously refused to authorize, she’s been slow-walking implementation of the Build Public Renewables Act which she signed in 2023. BPRA makes it easier for the New York Power Authority to build our renewable energy project that the private sector has repeatedly failed to do. The tools are there should Hochul ever decide to use them. 

A More Peaceful Nation

“The fault lies not in our stars but in ourselves,” Cassius tells Brutus, his fellow coup plotter, in William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar. If our leaders had any common sense, they would take the “L”, recognize that we have lost control of the Strait of Hormuz and aren’t getting it back. They could then withdraw all U.S forces from the Middle East, at long last. 

After two decades of failed forever wars, Wall Street engineered financial crashes, the January 6 coup plotters who went unpunished, an opposition party that barely tries to oppose and 77 million Americans voting to put Donald Trump in the White House for a second time, we have ceased being a serious nation. We have no business trying to run the world, much less the competence to do so. 

The Washington foreign policy establishment is an elite club. Its members are accustomed to thinking of themselves as masters of the universe. They will always reach for another weapons system like an alcoholic reaches for another drink. We could cut our nearly trillion dollar per year military budget in half and we would still have the highest-funded military in the world. 

There’s so much that’s neglected and broken in this country that needs care and fixing that those savings could be put to. Shedding our messianic militarism and all the violence abroad and at home that comes with that in favor of being one still-influential nation among others would be a blessing. We would no longer be a great nation. But, we could be a good one.

The Indypendent is a New York City-based newspaper, website and weekly radio show. All of our work is made possible by readers like you. During this holiday season, please consider making a recurring or one-time donation today or subscribe to our monthly print edition and get every copy sent straight to your home.