Menu

How Cuomo’s Attempt to Weaponize Rent Freeze Politics Against Mamdani Backfired

The former governor’s attack on Mamdani for having a rent-stabilized one bedroom apartment revealed how little he understood the plight of NYC renters, says the author of a new book on the 2025 mayor’s race.

Theodore Hamm Apr 23

Note: As the rent freeze debate heats up this spring, here’s a look back at an angry challenger’s ham-fisted attack on Zohran Mamdani’s signature campaign issue. It is an excerpt of Ted Hamm’s Meet Mayor Mamdani, now available from OR Books. 

Long before Zohran entered the race for mayor in late October 2024, “Freeze the Rent” had been a rallying cry for the NYC-DSA. Despite Andrew Cuomo’s evidence-free claims to the contrary, Mamdani repeatedly clarified on the campaign trail that his staple pledge only applied to the roughly one million apartment units overseen by New York City’s longstanding rent protection program. 

For example, in January 2025 blues poet and songstress Aja Monet welcomed Zohran to the stage at the WNYC Winter Jazzfest. In briefly introducing himself to a large nightclub audience, the DSA candidate talked up affordability and his desire to restore the “New York City dream.” “I will freeze the rent for every single rent-stabilized tenant in this city,” Mamdani declared. 

Although over 1.3 million additional apartments in the vast metropolis are unregulated, a rent freeze nonetheless would benefit nearly 2.5 million New York City residents, who saw a 12% total increase during the landlord-friendly Adams administration. 

Taking a cue from Republican strategist Karl Rove during the George W. Bush era, Cuomo decided that in the wake of Mamdani’s primary triumph, he would attack Zohran’s main source of strength: the DSA candidate’s support from rent-stabilized tenants, a category that includes nearly every demographic in the city. 

As governor, Cuomo cared infinitely more about Manhattan real estate developers than homeless families.

Such a move was politically perilous, given the reality that many people vote with their pocketbooks—and it’s not only lower-income New Yorkers that enjoy the benefits of rent protection. The program enables middle-income tenants to accrue familial wealth. Cuomo and his crew nonetheless seemed eager to slam Zohran over the issue, mainly because it enabled them to hurl bitter insults at the socialist who upset their apple cart. 

On Friday, August 8, Cuomo tossed a virtual Molotov cocktail. “Somewhere last night in New York City,” the former governor bellowed, “a single mother and her children slept at a homeless shelter because you, Assemblyman Mamdani, are occupying her rent-controlled apartment.” After a bunch of details about Zohran’s family income, including the legislator’s $142,000 salary, Cuomo’s lengthy X missive added lightning to its thunder, stating: “Leaders must show moral clarity. It’s time to move out.” 

Most unsurprisingly, Cuomo’s eviction notice caught fire on Elon Musk’s bot-ridden platform, with the initial post capturing 35 million views by mid-September (and related statements garnering millions more eyeballs). In the Age of Trump, fiery incoherence flies. For the hordes encouraged by billionaires to hate socialists, the blistering assault furnished a double shot of dopamine. 

But upon close inspection, the Fight and Deliver dude’s carefully scripted attack amounted to little more than sandbox-level taunting. As governor, Cuomo cared infinitely more about Manhattan real estate developers than homeless families. And the claim that people currently living in shelters could even afford $2,300 in monthly rent was pure hogwash. Indeed, the guy who pays nearly $100,000 per year for a Manhattan luxury rental reinforced Zohran’s frequent critique that the longtime suburbanite was out of touch with everyday New Yorkers. 

Cuomo’s scattershot assault was nonetheless very much on brand. Like the Fight and Deliver candidate, the statement was nasty, brutish, and mean—or some combination thereof. The father of three daughters even blasted Zohran’s intercontinental wedding celebrations, thereby insulting the Democratic nominee’s family heritage. One month later, Cuomo smeared Zohran’s mother, echoing New York Post insinuations that Qatari investor funding for Mira Nair’s films somehow linked her to Islamic extremism.

In his desperate bid to score points, the veteran pol weaponized his own family tree. On the same day as the rent attack, the flailing challenger issued a high-testosterone warning: 

In case you forgot, I’m Andrew Cuomo, son of Mario, grandson of Andrea. 

Welcome to the heavyweight bout, @ZohranKMamdani. 

This is a two-man race. You look tired already. It’s just the second round. 

Rather than Sylvester Stallone’s “Rocky,” Cuomo sounded more like Jerry Quarry, the “Great White Hope” contender that Muhammad Ali famously pummeled in three rounds.  

“I live rent-free in his head,” Zohran quipped in response to Cuomo’s ginned-up outrage. Gothamist reporters Brigid Bergin and Elizabeth Kim soon paid a mid-August visit to Mamdani’s Astoria apartment building. One resident told them that the place is “comfortable, but nothing special.” None of Mamdani’s neighbors told Bergin or Kim that the assemblymember’s salary qualified as exorbitant. 

Along with tenant advocates across the city, the DSA candidate’s Astoria neighbors denounced “Zohran’s Law,” a headline-friendly proposal by Cuomo that would require rent-stabilized tenants to pay at least 30% of their yearly income to landlords or leave the program. Instead of bolstering the economic security of renters, the initiative promised a windfall for building owners, many of which are Wall Street private equity firms. Cuomo’s faux-populist outrage against Mamdani caused him to advance deeply unpopular plans, a rather problematic strategy for a struggling contender. 

The Indypendent is a New York City-based newspaper, website and weekly radio show. All of our work is made possible by readers like you. During this holiday season, please consider making a recurring or one-time donation today or subscribe to our monthly print edition and get every copy sent straight to your home.