Supporters of Mayor Mamdani’s Pied-à-Terre Tax Decry Lawsuit by Wealthy Property Owners
The pied-à-terre tax targets luxury secondary residences in New York City, and is expected to generate $500 million in yearly revenue for the City.
More than a dozen New Yorkers, community leaders, and elected officials rallied Wednesday outside the Brooklyn Appellate Courthouse in support of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s pied-à-terre tax–which imposes a surcharge on luxury non-primary residences–and condemned recent lawsuits challenging the policy.
Standing alongside advocates from Make the Road – New York, Desis Rising Up and Moving, Professional Staff Congress–CUNY, among others, Brahvan Ranga, a campaign manager with Invest in Our New York, addressed the crowd, but also the plaintiffs suing the City. “Our message to them is simple. Cry me a river,” he said facetiously.
“Our message to them is simple. Cry me a river.”
Ranga continued by addressing the struggles that many New Yorkers face everyday. “They can’t afford their groceries, they can’t afford their rent, and they can’t afford their child care, while our city faces a multi-billion dollar budget crisis,” he said. “The pied-à-terre tax is an important first step to address that crisis, fund crucial government services that New Yorkers rely on, and give Mayor Mamdani the money he needs to enact his wildly popular affordability agenda.”
The pied-à-terre tax emerged from Mayor Mamdani’s campaign promise to tax the rich, as well as the need to manage the City’s ever-increasing budget gap. As a yearly surcharge levied on one-to-three-family homes valued at more than $5 million and condos or co-op units valued at $1 million, it targets property that is not occupied as a primary residence for the owner, an immediate family member, or a tenant. Additionally, the pied-à-terre tax is projected to provide the City with $500 million in recurring revenue.
In response to Mayor Mamdani’s pied-à-terre tax, property owners have filed multiple lawsuits over the implementation and constitutionality of the tax. Last month, Judge Wayne M. Ozzi of the Supreme Court of the State of New York for Richmond County ruled that the Department of Finance’s rollout of the tax was “arbitrary, capricious, and unlawful,” per the ruling. Following Judge Ozzi’s decision, the City quickly sought to overturn the ruling and filed an appeal.
On Wednesday morning, as the court heard oral arguments regarding the city’s appeal, the speakers derided the plaintiffs in the case. DSA-backed State Senator Jabari Brisport was among those to criticize the property owners for choosing to prioritize their time and money to fight the yearly surcharge in court.
State Senator Brisport mused, “when it is time to spend money on childcare, on transit, on our schools, on our hospitals, all of a sudden they [have] a problem. All of a sudden, it’s not worth it. All of a sudden, they [have to] take us to court.” He concluded, “this is a frivolous lawsuit. We are gonna win. We are going to tax the rich. This is just the beginning.”
Throughout the rally, speakers advocated for implementing widespread progressive taxes across New York State. Specifically, they called for the Invest in Our New York Campaign to be passed during next year’s state legislative session, which introduces new taxes on income, corporate profits, capital gains, inheritances, and high-value assets. State Assemblymember Diana Moreno, also a democratic socialist, told the crowd, “This is the floor, not the ceiling … We are gonna pass the whole IONY package, because that is what is required to guarantee working New Yorkers a dignified life. And that is what we’re fighting for.”




