Return From The Killing Fields. NYC Woman Confronts Her Brother’s Actions In Iraq
Editor’s Note: I first met Leah Larson while covering an antiwar protest in fall of 2003. While most of the crowd around her screamed and chanted, she spoke quietly of her love for her brother, a young Marine, and of her deep sense of dread over what the newly launched Iraq War would do to him. She was as concerned that he would lose his soul as his life and that their relationship would be shattered forever. When I spoke with Leah again this fall, her brother had just returned from a nine-month tour of duty in Iraq and her worst nightmares had been confirmed. Her reflections on what has happened to her family are a reminder that the calamity of war extends far beyond the battlefield. —John Tarleton
Two days after he came home from Iraq, my older brother showed me some pictures. “I just bombed that building,” he said. In the photo, children in Fallujah are clustered beside their broken school.
During his first two weeks back, my brother, the demolitions expert, plied me with photos of the carnage and mayhem wreaked by his platoon. Fifteen memory cards worth of bizarre and disturbing photos – half-naked soldiers dancing in the desert, a severed goat’s head in a noose, Marines dressed in traditional women’s clothing found following a house raid.
I wanted to hit him, banish him, to create a giant dent in his soul. But he wouldn’t care, wouldn’t budge. This is what the Marines have trained him to do – warp, destroy and believe it is for good.
WAR GAMES
My brother can be as sweet as sugarcane with a laugh that pours loudly into your ears. He has a clumsy way of affection, like when he comes home drunk and knocks on my window to tell how much he loves his little sister. He remembers my lopsided pigtails, chicken pox, first kiss, my love for manatees and my favorite vegetarian food. Scarcely two years apart, our experiences are parallel and echo one another, even our experience of war.
We used to play war together. He would dress me as a soldier, paint my face in the colors of Earth and hunt me down before dinnertime. While we are both part Cherokee, our mother says our warrior spirits have gone in different directions. My brother first became my enemy, my pain and my conflict when he enlisted in the military while struggling in his high school’s Special Ed program, where teachers thought him a slow, hopeless, uncontrollable idiot. He often fought with other students who would make fun of his facial features with taunts like “bubba lip don’t trip.”
When recruiters came to take my brother, I howled, groped, twisted, shivered, barely escaping the horrible separation from him. At a young age, long before I recognized politics, my spirit understood many things. I knew that if he joined the military, somehow our kinship would be severed, and it has been. It saddens me when I am unable to hug him because he cannot tolerate affection. Our mother likes to tell stories of when my brother could only be comforted by his GI Joe toys. Lying in the top bunk, while I slept on the bottom, my brother would watch a sky of little green men dangle from the ropes he tied to the ceiling.
Now, instead of green men, my brother keeps metal, wood and crystal beaded crosses in his room. Some hang over pictures of friends killed in the war. Others occupy the bare spaces left on the wall, which are few. Next to a particularly large cross, a picture of the atomic bomb blast in Japan unfurls next to his video games. He goes to the mall, the gym, eats grandma’s meatballs and goes out drinking with friends. He seems to think nothing of his crimes as he makes plans to go to church, as he prepares for his 25th birthday, as he has sex with a woman for the first time in nine months.
Sometimes I stare at the pictures I stole from his sneaker box, the ones that he didn’t want me to see, including one of a man he killed. It is not tears that come but the impossible question of forgiveness. Brains and blood were once safe and alive in this being. My brother blew open the back of his head and took a picture of the gore coming out. He believes there is a ghost in his room. Sometimes he feels a breath touching on his shoulders and back. I know it is the spirits of those he killed, and helped to kill, following him, reaching for him, asking him their own silent questions. Perhaps he surrounds himself with crosses because he knew they would come.
It is only when he is drunk that his guilt emerges from under the amber smog of Jack Daniels. “Sis,” he asked one night, “would you rather have me do whatever I needed to do to come home, or die because I couldn’t do what I needed to do to come home?” In his question lay a plea for forgiveness. Sitting across from him in my room, I didn’t know how to answer. If he had been killed, would that make me support this war? How would I feel toward Iraqis?
My brother’s possible death demented our family. I prepared for it every day, imagining what his funeral would be like and what I would tell my future children about their uncle. It became impossible to live with my parents. My mother’s changing moods left us isolated from each other. My father’s blustering support of the war (“I hope we level that whole damn country of ragheads”) was infuriating.
A BIRTHDAY TO REMEMBER
My brother’s recent 25th birthday celebration was a breaking point for me. On that night, a bunch of his old friends joined him to mark the occasion. I wanted to be close with everyone, sharing in the celebrations and camaraderie. Before we left for a bar in the city, we clustered into my brother’s room. He began to do his usual flaunting of pictures and videos much to the enjoyment of his friends. I sat farthest from his computer, turning my eyes away from the country he helped destroy. My brother’s friends eventually fell into an awful silence. Moving from my seat, I wanted to see what they were watching.
A young man, who appeared to be in his early 20s, was centered in my brother’s computer screen. The man was blindfolded and sobbing as his head rested on his own knee. Heavy metal music filled the speakers as my brother forced headphones onto his ears. You could hear him laughing while saying, “you’re gonna die,” as my brother pushed the camera into the young man’s face with his left hand and slapped him hard with his right hand. I watched tears of agony escape from the prisoner’s cheeks and fall onto his pants. He was heaving from the suffering. Arabic was pouring out from his mouth. No one understood the words, but I knew he was begging for his life.
I did not stay to see what had happened. My brother’s room remained silent. There was no “Yo, this shit is awesome!” or “You gotta e-mail me this!” I am almost certain the young prisoner was killed, although I did not watch the rest of the video. All these years of trying to balance my hatred for war and the love for my brother immediately tipped to one side. I did not want to be near him anymore. I did not want to go out for his birthday. How could I? The family of the young prisoner likely mourns while I get to party with his abuser. After finishing the video, my brother yelled upstairs to see if his birthday cake was ready.
A few days ago, I asked a mutual childhood friend, who was in my brother’s room that night watching the video, what had happened in the end. His response was, “Who are you with right now? Why are you asking me this? There is no need for an answer so you should forget about it.” I continually wonder why our friends and family protect my brother from the truth of his actions. In this way, he will never consciously recognize the horror of what he has done or begin to heal himself. My brother came home shortly after our childhood friend notified him that I was asking strange questions. He said, “Listen, I don’t want you in my room. I know you’re a protester or whatever but I don’t want no phone calls from any newspapers and crap.” Someday I’ll find the strength to finish watching the video, but torture or murder, I haven’t yet forgiven my brother for either.
*Leah Larson is a pseudonym. She currently teaches troubled teens at a Brooklyn high school.


are you seriously pretending to have evidence of murders being comitted by us fukhead soldiers and you are doing nothing about it? why is the so called “anti” war movement so incapable of doing anything that actually might be construed as anti war? you want to work to end the war? STEAL THE VIDEO OF US SOLDIERS MURDERING AN IRAQI PRISONER AND POST IT! jeezuz, we are blowing people to bits here…when are we going to start acting like it?
This is not just an anti-war movement, this is my brother. The war is not going to be stopped by putting young people like my brother in jail, it is the people that sent him, forced him, made him to go and do their bidding.
If you analyzed the article more closely you would understand alot more.
I understand your dilemma but this is probably not an isolated case. And this young Iraqi was also someone’s brother, son maybe even husband and father. The atrocities that go on there are all but unrecognised here, the media et al preferring to focus on the atrocities committed by insurgents and a so called “few bad apples”. I can see that you are damned if you do and damned if you don’t – but you have to live with yourself I would say ask yourself if you can live with knowing that your brother is (maybe as you haven’t seen the whole tape) responsible and or complicit in murder and you stayed silent which amounts to complicity both ethically and legally. He is at the very least responsible for torture & abuse.
And one wonders why the Iraqi’s hate Americans. Maybe you should contact a professional ( even a Newspaper, what about the Christian Science Monitor, they seem to have ethics paramount) you can trust and discuss this
as I am sure it is also extremely hard on you knowing what your brother has done, and quite frankly it sounds like he really needs some professional help. You say your brother was in a Special ED class- do you think it’s morally OK for people with problems to be recruited as soldiers, the soldier responsible for the rape of the 14 year old Iraqi girl also had problems – maybe you could see it that way and get some attention as to recruiting criteria and how it puts a gun in the hands of young people with probelms knowing (yes knowing) that they will very likely abuse their power! Not all soldiers commit atrocities – those that do, I believe, already had problems and more than likely would have been or will be arrested or guilty of some kind of abuse without having been to Iraq. What your brother did is unspeakable (and worse he views it as entertainment for his friends) and the fact that it is a war does not make it excusable. Also withholding this allows for it to go on and it is probably a lot more endemic than we would like to believe. War is an insane action, but people support it because they are protected from exactly these kinds of abuses and images so they can pretend it is heroic. The Whitehouse can say a “few bad apples” because people in your position refuse to give evidence to the contrary. Having said that I know it will take a huge amount of courage and suffering on your part to go public with this, but think of the enormous suffering of that Iraqi boy and the fact that as I am writing this the same thing is more than likely happening to some other boy, girl, man, women, child in Iraq.
P.S. The Army did not force your brother to abuse and kill a young Iraqi – or did they?
This is not just an anti-war movement, this is my brother. The war is not going to be stopped by putting young people like my brother in jail, it is the people that sent him, forced him, made him to go and do their bidding.
You’re right it won’t stop the war, but if everyone who had knowledge like you do and I am sure there are thousands or more, it would force peoople to see what a crime war is. Hard as it is – your brother joined the army, he was not drafted. He chose to do these atrocious things, there are other soldiers who have stood up against abuse at a great price to themselves: alienation, cries of traitor, dishonorable discharge, even murdered, in the Vietnam war. I know you don’t want your brotther to go to jail, but in remaining silent you are complict in what the “people that sent him” are doing.
Your brother did it because he could, and from what you say, appeared to be proud of his actions, why else show it to his friends. What if that young boy was a local boy? How would you feel then, what would you do? If he is troubled then he needs help. What if he does it again here? It might help to see it in that context, after all abuse is abuse and murder is murder wherever it is carried out. And regardless of whether you’re a soldier in a war zone or not, it is wrong and many soldiers would not be a part of what your brother did, so you can’t blame the war, the army, the situation for everything. He needs help and you are in a position to help him – heartbreaking though the results might be, and by becoming public you could also shed light on the criminality of war, standards for enlistment and lack of oversight, gross negligence in the field.
It seems obvious you want to do something or why post this. Surely you must know it will be easy to find out who you are given your location, job and that your brother served in Iraq. A mea culpa via the internet is really not enough, that’s how the Abu Ghraib scandal started. Take control now of how you want to present this before a newspaper uses it to further an agenda or hide the complicity of the Army, Goverenment etc. and you are arrested as “withholding information to a crime”.
You know, it is very hard being in the grey area. This is why military families do not speak out. Most leftists do not find themsleves in this kinda greyness.
“Surely you must know it will be easy to find out who you are given your location, job and that your brother served in Iraq.”
I hope that this is not a threat nor a promise. What a ridculous way to treat eachother. Obviously I am doing what I can and I will not tolerate being pushed, coerced or attacked.
I can happily live with myself. Do not insult me.
Most wars (and war lords) thrive on ignorance and prey on the young. Young soldiers are the most physicaly fit for service and still do not have the life experience neccesarry to create thier own set of beliefs based on a full life experience, that will prevent them from commiting these type of acts. Do not blame your brother. That’s just war. There is no, fair or antiseptic war. It’s always men doing horrible thing to each other. He will have to confront his demons at his own time and in his own way. You are part of you brothers basic circle of existence. Give him the one thing you can and that nobody else can wich is your love free of prejudice. Eventually (probably a long proccess) he will come around and he will need you and your family more tha ever.
It was not meant as an insult, note these are questions not judgements. And of course It is not a threat and if you had read the lines – this is preceded by “it is obvious you want to do something” – if not you would have hidden all details as to your identity and not even wrtten this article. Also it was neither, pushing, coercing or attacking but asking questions and pointing out facts. I am sure soldiers & their families who do not torture, abuse and murder the people in a war tone arena – are equally offended when there name is slurred because of a few.
As for leftists I wouldn’t know, but I am sure most people in the world find themsleves in this kinda greyness, just look at wars, civil unrest, brutaility, it is the people who know and sit in silence that allow it to go on and that includes pretty much everyone, we are all to blame.
Why did you write it anyway.
Why did you make this public?
Your brother committed a crime, you seem to want to protect him, this is a weird way of doing that.
You published an article on the interenet, millions if not billions of people can read it what were your reaons, what were you thinking? and in a newspaper not even a blog. It makes the miltary look bad, and yet you claim to be from a military family.
Or is this some kind of sick hoax, and none of it’s true. We have no way to prove any of whta you have written is true.
Why did you do it?
Is this for real , did you question the sources’ motives before promising anonymity and fact check. (see Ethics for Jourmalism)
If you did it would be interesting to know what reasons you have for publishing an article about a war crime committed complete with evidence available & known perpetrators.
I can see why this would be of interest given the news these days & the various trials of soldiers going on around the States, and the heartbreak for their families. But, the article does a great disservice, ironically both to the military (those who would never commit these crimes or hide them) & pacifists , but most of all to the Iraqis who are murdered and tortured by US soldiers, while people like this decide to reveal gory brutalities hidden behind anonymity, thus allowing this state of affairs to be perpetuated.
What was his/her motivation and are you sure he/she was/is telling the truth?
Maybe you have a very good reason for printing this?
Yours, confounded, confused and appaulled.
How often do military family members say anything at all about the atrocities committed by their sons, brothers, husbands? This woman deserves our support not condemnation. Some of you are about as compassionate and understanding as an artillery shell. If I was in her situation, I don’t know if I could bring myself to possibly send my brother away to prison for years if not decades.
Observer – You seem to be forgetting the poor man who was so brutally destroyed and that her brother is guilty of murder.
Yes the writer deserves compassion, I am sure it is terrible for her, but she has not spoken out, she remains unknown, what she says cannot be proved, how do we even know she is not a he in fact not him or just anti-military rakeing up the muck! If it’s genuine there are support groups for Military families and personnel who want to speak out, that might be a good place to start instead of an anonymous article.
Does anyone here have someone close to them in a way that war invaded their families to the point where U.S or Iraqi, it doesn’t matter anymore, since war is so disgusting all around?
You cannot judge a person until you walk in their shoes.
Does it matter that we know why I wrote what I did or do you need to hear that I am feeling pain and alot of conflict? Is that newsworthy enough? Should I denounce my brother, sending him to jail because society has failed him because he didn’t live the life of a privledged white person where he could have gone to good schools, live in the best of neighborhoods, and parents that graduated from college? I wrote for the Indy because I thought it would be a safe space to share, but instead I am dumbfounded by the lack of not even sensitivity or empathy, but by the self-righteous assholes that are plaguing any type of movement, particularly one that reaches certain communities and peoples.
It’s like if my brother killed a cop instead, I bet you would want to protect him with police brutality slogans and would think it wrong if I chose to testify against him in court.
Who places value on life? I don’t and neither do you.
I don’t believe our justice system will do shit to correct the wrongs any of us can do.
I have spoken out. What the hell have you done with your demons lately?
I submitted this note (below) to the Indypendent, with the request that it be passed along to “Leah.” It was not until I read the previous comments posted here that I realized even more how difficult the position is of being closely related to an active soldier. It is much easier to be certain and stand by one’s principles, and in the process to criticize the action or inaction of those who do not abide by those principles, when you stand outside the ring. Inside, things become much blurrier. My own experience has taught me that I knew significantly more about what people “should do” before my brother went to war. It is evident that the critics on this page sit comfortably outside the action, wishing to passionately direct that action, rather than listening to the people who are in the midst of it.
I wanted to write and thank you for your thoughtful
piece ‘Return from the Killing Fields.’ It is uncanny how
much your experience seems to mirror mine – I also am
strongly opposed to the Iraq war and have a brother who is a
demo expert in the Marine Corps. He recently embarked on his
second tour in Iraq, and the hardships and conflicts suffered
by myself and my family members are difficult to communicate
even to my closest friends. Your struggle to maintain a close
relationship with your brother and your aborted attempts at
forgiveness spoke my own difficulties.
Thank you for bravely confronting an extremely complicated
and often ignored issue that is unfortunately being faced by
many of us.
It must be a painful position to be in a brother that you love who has committed a brutal crime you do well to show the humanity, the affcetion the joys, that pain and sorrow of this relationship. War crimes ara a complicated, mindnumbing, ignored subject, but you say this man (your brother) filmed and photographed the torture and death of others and took part. don’t the victims families also deserve compassion, justice, support, maybe that young man who was brutalised had a sister too. Why was your brother’s life dependent on these acts? “would you rather have me do whatever I needed to do to come home, or die because I couldn’t do what I needed to do to come home?” If filming and photographing the torture and murder of people is “ordered” isn’t that something to speak up about, or was it peer pressure, would he have been killed if he didn’t take part (shades of Vietnam)? Maybe you could write a follow up and explain this as those of us not in the military are hard pressed to understand and thus you have those “wishing to passionately direct that action, rather than listening to the people who are in the midst of it”. As Appreciative says “I knew significantly more about what people “should do” before my brother went to war”, what about those of us who don’t have a brother, sister who has gone off to war. Comments say “we” the uninitiated don’t understand – so enlighten us, take down the green wall of silence and tell the world what these young men & women face and what it does to them, you have only explained what it has done to you.
sharing your thoughts in a Newspaper was maybe not the best way to go, especially one with a comment section. You put your experience and feelings in a public domain and other people are sharing their feelings, you might no want to hear them Didn’t the editor explain this might happen? I am sad that you are in this position it has to be painful. But it also has to be painful for the Iraqis, and those soldiers families who have seen their sons, daughters go to prison, and those whose sons, daughters have been treated cruelly because they refused to do these kinds of things. War is brutal and disgusting, but until we take responsibility for our complicity whether it’s supporting war, concealing crimes, remaining silent, hiding mental illness, post traumatic stress bought on by being in a war zone not much will change. I do have military relatives and a cousin who was dishonorably discharged for abuse.
You sure have bought up one of the most fundamental splits in the human psyche. We are taught killing is wrong and then we train young impressionable people to kill , put them in a war arena with little oversight and a message to get the job done, even with rewards for the most kills, then we wonder why atrocities are committed some losing the ability to differentiate between what might be called a “good killing” where they are heroes and get a medal, and a “bad killing” where they are deemed murderer’s and go to prison, and to make it worse we make them reliant on their friends judgement ‘sand vice versa , and depend on them to save their lives. What isn’t fucked up about this?
“Should I denounce my brother, sending him to jail because society has failed him because he didn’t live the life of a privledged white person where he could have gone to good schools, live in the best of neighborhoods, and parents that graduated from college?”
Sad though your story is, you should really quit blaming the world for your brother’s mistakes, society might have failed him but he also failed himself , he chose to torture & kill someone, if you read the news, middle class white kids have done the same and gone to prison for it. And there are many poor underpriveledged people who have never done anything like this – it’s not what you have it’s who you are and whether you choose to take responsibility for your life or just pass the buck.
“Should I denounce my brother…”
You can do that or share the blood on his hands. It’s your choice.
“…society has failed him because he didn’t live the life of a privledged white person where he could have gone to good schools, live in the best of neighborhoods, and parents that graduated from college?”
Society didn’t force him to become a torturer or a murderer.
You are currently complicit in war crimes. Unless you take immediate steps to prevent future atrocities, you will share responsibility for them.
seriously, nightwalker, and everyone who is saying things similar to what you are saying, i say this: you people are a fucking joke. who the hell do you think you are? all you care is your stupid self righteousness. you obviously dont give a fuck about “people” and their feelings at all. All you care about is your stupid leftist ideals. Guess what, they mean NOTHING if you dont moderate them with UNDERSTANDING AND EMPATHY. Here you people are, like a bunch of jackasses, showing your fake-as-hell empathy for the tortured Iraqis and being complete DICKS to someone with a real dilemma, who supported the war as little as you did. You just want to hang her out to dry so you can see her videos on tv and yell and scream about how right you were that the American military is running Iraq like a fascist regime. You greedy jackasses. I sat there and read that damn compelling story and almost fell out of my chair when I saw some of the stuff you people were saying. You should fucking be ashamed of yourself. This is EXACTLY why I refuse to identify with the “Left” anymore. You’re all equally as huge self-righteous egocentric jackasses as the far right. You may one day end up in a situation where someone you love has the opportunity to send you to prison, and you would have to count your blessings if ur fortunate enough to have that person be something like “Leah.” Family is way more important than any fucking war. Is it really that important to get another torture video so you can tell everyone “I told you so.”
yeah. many of ur responses really pissed me off. and im not some Kansas conservative. im a liberal new jerseyan who used to proudly associate with the left until i realized how many leftists are so caught up in themselves they forget the EMPATHY that used to define the left.
This was a gut wrenching article. Good work to The Indy for finding this writer.
Hey everyone, “Leah Larson” here….Alot of these comments did hurt, but I also recognize that people are outraged and should be. It oftentimes gets directed at the wrong person. I completely agree with what “wow” says. I don’t identify with the left anymore because I find many use real lives to feed their self-righteousness. Most leftists, those that I have encountered and that’s been quite a few, don’t have any huge moral dilemmas or find themselves in the grey area. I say to those people to really read the article. Read. I am outraged too, but conflicted in so many other ways that you have no understanding for. If you need to know, I don’t have any guilt, or feel “blood on my hands” because I refuse to throw my brother in jail. I am so much more closer to the war in a different way that most people are. You wouldn’t believe the different layers there are. It consumes you. But, we all do feel it somehow.
This is all totally fucked up, but I don’t think throwing soldiers in jail is going to work. We have to get to the root of all this, otherwise it turns into a witch hunt.
Insert troops into a hell on earth and there’s no way to prevent atrocities. Yet the real fiends in their capital suites are never spattered with a single drop of blood.
Cowards go after this or that individual. What requires courage, and tests those who so easily condemn this man, is whether they will act, taking the risks involved in organizing to bring down the whole Imperial system and the politicians who benefit from it, once and for all.
I blame the government for its lies and deceit–for chewing up young people and spitting them out to control resources like oil.
People who join the military are, for the most part, people of integrity before and after they join up. The people writing imbecilic comments above probably don’t know any troops personally, and you have no idea what you’re talking about. The armed forces exploit everything about them, including their loyalty to their buddies and need to stay alive and get home, to accomplish their sick goals. People who comment here need to know who the real murderers are the lying capitalists that pimp the troops–our brothers and sisters–for the goals of empire. Most troops are against the war. I bet you didn’t know that either.
By the way, I sure as hell don’t think you’re going to stop the war by calling troops murderers. If you are willing to work with them and support their organizing, they have the power to stop the war. Know your history. This worked in Vietnam.
To Thomas F Barton and Katherine…very well said. If I wasnt so shocked and angered by the comments preceding my first one, I believe I would’ve said something very similar.
I know you all probably despise the Bush circle here, and so do I. But this isn’t Karl Rove that people were attacking here, it was a seemingly average American like any of us. The big dogs at the top would LOVE to see that people were focusing on the troops’ misbehavior rather than their own. I mean, isn’t that how they played off the first wave of torture footage?