RGB: Rent Gouging Bastards
At a sleepy June 1 Rent Guidelines Board (RGB) meeting, a few tenant advocates sat idly while the board’s two tenant members made a resolution in support of home rule. Though Mayor Bloomberg is tepidly against the issue – restoring power over rent and eviction laws to city council – no one could foresee how the mayor’s appointed board chairman Marvin Markus would react.
Tenant groups claim home rule is essential to solving the housing crisis because city council members are more accountable to tenants than state lawmakers.Preparing to give testimony in support of home rule, tenant lawyer and former RGB Executive Director Tim Collins approached the nine-member board when landlord representative Harold Lubell commented it was inappropriate for the RGB to take policy positions. “Make your motion,” Markus said to the board’s tenant members. Markus then did a roll call to vote the home rule resolution down.
The four public members dared not to buck Markus because they are mayoral appointees. Collins then muttered to Lubell that he supported past RGB resolutions on landlord hardships, prompting Markus to bark, “Be quiet you!” Collins rebutted, “This is a disgrace to the democratic process.” That triggered Markus’ tirade against the lawyer Collins. “What do you know about the democratic process?” When Collins asked if the public meeting was being recorded, Markus went ballistic, “Get the fuck out of here! If you want to sue us, so sue us!” Markus’ dropping of an f-bomb marks the opening of rent season.
Later this month the city Rent Guidelines Board will meet and undoubtedly raise the rents for New York’s more than 2 million rent-stabilized tenants. I say “undoubtedly” because the outcome is never in question. The RGB always raises your rents even in the face of stagnating tenant incomes, soaring landlord profits and poor housing conditions for lowincome renters.
So what is the Rent Guidelines Board?The RGB has nine members: five “public members,” two landlord representatives, and two tenant representatives, all appointed by the mayor. Marvin Markus, the chair, exercises great influence over the public members and the board as a whole. All five public members (including Markus) are highly paid professionals, and only tenant representative Adriene Holder is a renter.
Each year, the tenant representatives propose rent freezes, pointing out the city’s obvious affordability crisis, but the board votes them down. The landlord members propose ridiculously high increases, and they are voted down too. Then Markus and the public members play the “reasonable middle ground” and vote in rent increases that are lower than the landlord representatives’ proposals, but still steadily price people out of the city. Housing groups and tenant lawyers criticize the RGB’s yearly decision to raise rents based solely on landlords’ operating costs such as labor contracts and fuel, saying the board never takes into account tenants’ ability to pay the rent. Renters’ incomes dropped 5.6 percent from 2001-2004 after inflation, and rent-stabilized tenants’ incomes dropped 8.6 percent in the same period. Thus, even this year’s proposed increases, which will fall somewhere between 3 and 8.5 percent, could threaten thousands of tenants with the prospect of losing their homes. Let’s meet the RGB members.
Chair (Public Member)
MARVIN MARKUS
Term length: Serves at pleasure of Mayor
Known to tenants as “Marvin Markup,” Markus works at Goldman Sachs as a managing director and investment banker in municipal financing. He earned his nickname as chair of the RGB in the early 1980s, when it raised rents an astronomical 11 and 14 percent at a time when arson was the landlords’ preferred tool to deal with ailing apartments. Markus is rumored to have orchestrated the ouster in 2006 of Martin Zelnik, who voted for a rent freeze last year.
Public Member
BETTY PHILLIPS ADAMS
Term length: 4 years
Term ends 12/31/2006
Betty Phillips Adams incurs the ire of tenants because unlike the other “public members,” she gives lip service to the affordability crisis and has a social services background, but then votes for rent increases without missing a beat. Adams often looks uninterested during meetings. She is currently president of the Metro-Manhattan Community Foundation and does management consulting for non-profits. Prior to that, she was president and CEO of the Jackie Robinson Foundation for almost 10 years.
Public Member
GALE D. KAUFMAN
Term length: 4 years
Term ends 12/31/2006
Gale Kaufman is the most overtly pro-landlord public member. Behind the scenes she is known for her snide comments and arrogance, and can throw a hell of a tantrum. She once pitched a fit during a tour tenant advocacy groups gave of distressed buildings: When her van pulled up to a building in the Bronx, Kaufman spied a throng of reporters and refused to budge from her seat. She did not want to be put on the spot about bad conditions in buildings and how she invariably will vote for rent increases. She is the managing director at Duvernay + Brooks LLC, a real estate finance and development firm.
Public Member
JONATHAN L. KIMMEL, ESQ.
Term length: 3 years
Term ends 12/31/2007
Kimmel is new to the board. Tenants had hoped he would take up the position held by Martin Zelnik, the most responsive public member to tenant concerns. But it appears that he will march in lock step with Markus; so far, he’s voted with Markus on the range of rent increases and against a home rule resolution. He is currently of counsel at Sanders & Deconinck, LLP. Prior to that, he worked for 14 years as legal director of the city teachers’ retirement system.
Public Member
LESLIE WRIGHT, ESQ.
Term length: 2 years
Term ends 12/31/2006
Leslie Wright, the other new member, has
not made much of an impression because
she has rarely engaged tenants or tenant
advocates on issues. She comes off as the consummate paper-pusher that one would expect from someone who works on “complex real-estate transactions.” Leslie Wright is a Senior Associate at Marcus Attorneys, where she specializes in complex real estate transactions involving the creation of multitiered financing structures for nonprofit organizations.
Owner Representative
HAROLD LUBELL, ESQ.
Term length: 2 years
Term ends 12/31/2006
Lubell is known for shaking his finger at tenants while chiding them that the RGB is not a welfare agency. He enjoys the crotchety old-man shtick and could play billionaire Burns in an off-Broadway production of The Simpsons. When tenants demanded rent freezes last year, Lubell snarled back about rising landlord costs, using Bushesque logic to argue for rent increases, “It’s for your benefit and the board’s benefit.” He is a partner at Bryan Cave, a massive corporate-law firm.
Owner Representative
STEVEN J. SCHLEIDER
Term length: 3 years
Term ends 12/31/2007
Steven Schleider is the other landlord representative. He also votes and argues for high rent increases. He is an appraiser and the president of Metropolitan Valuation Services, Inc. He has over 25 years experience in real estate.
Tenant Representative
ADRIENE L. HOLDER, ESQ.
Term length: 3 years
Term ends 12/31/2007
Holder, a Legal Aid attorney, is the more active and vocal of the tenant representatives. Both she and David Pagan introduce rent freezes each year that are invariably voted down by the public members and landlord representatives. Holder is the only renter on the entire board. Earlier this month, she tried introducing a home-rule resolution, which was the impetus for Markus’ enraged outburst.
Tenant Representative
DAVID PAGAN
Term length: 2 years
Term ends 12/31/2006
Pagan is the less active tenant representative on the board, but can be counted on to back rent freezes and home rule. He is the longtime executive director of Los Sures, a nonprofit community-development organization in Southside Williamsburg.
Tenants can testify at the RGB community hearings June 19 at Hostos College in the Bronx and June 22 at Cooper Union by calling 212-385-2934. The final vote on June 27 at Cooper Union will surely be rowdy.
Bennett Baumer is an organizer for the Met Council on Housing.


I wonder if former RGB exec. director Tim Collins feels like the RGB is legitimate anymore and did he feel it was during his tenure? Does Collins want to see the RGB abolished? The RGB seems like such a rigged process and the appointees, as pointed out in the article, are not representative of the public.
Why New York City Needs Home Rule Over Rent and Eviction Protections:
Tenants are paying high rent burdens in a shrinking supply of affordable regulated apartments, and the city has no power to change the housing policies that are making this situation worse:
• In 1970, the average tenant household paid 20 percent of income for rent. Today, the average household pays over 31 percent of income for rent. Nearly 29 percent of city tenants devote over half their incomes to rent – the highest figure ever.
• The state legislature weakened the rent laws several times in the 1990’s and again in 2003. These changes have made it easier for landlords to raise rents precipitously in low and moderate-income neighborhoods. The combination of high vacancy allowances, preferential rents and the 4 year rule has meant that tenants all over the city cannot find a vacant affordable rent stabilized apartment when they need to move. Since the first change in 1993, it is estimated that 200,000 units have been lost from regulation.
• The past decade has seen the largest increase in homelessness since the Great Depression. The number of families sleeping in city shelters has doubled since the 1980’s and children have become the largest and fastest growing segment of the homeless population.
• In 2003 alone, the real estate industry contributed 3 million dollars to upstate legislators and political action committees. None of the upstate legislators who engineered the changes in the rent laws are accountable to New York City residents suffering from this housing situation.
Loss of Affordable Housing:
New York City is currently undergoing the largest loss of affordable housing seen in recent times. Rent stabilized housing is the only affordable housing resource left to most low and moderate-income tenants. However, once they have been priced out of their apartment, rent stabilized tenants have no other options. Currently, the market for rentals and coops/condos is so strong that owners are able to ask for rents and prices well above what the median renter can afford – in every neighborhood of the city.
• 23% of the city’s 120,917 subsidized apartments were lost between 1990 and 2005; another 13% are soon to be lost;
• Within the subsidized stock, the city’s Mitchell-Lama housing has lost the most – 22,688 (over a third) apartments
• In addition, we lost over 14,000 units of rent stabilized housing in 2005
Close to 1,700 units were lost through coop/condo conversion
Over 1,700 units were lost through tax abatement expirations and substantial rehabilitations
Over 9,000 units were lost through high rent/vacancy decontrol
Affordability: The Rent Guidelines Board needs to consider the question of affordability and whether the rent increases they adopt are affordable to rent-stabilized tenants. If the Board adopts the high increases proposed at the preliminary vote, they will create further financial hardship for NYC tenants. This will only add to NYC’s housing crisis.
• Incomes of Rent Stabilized Tenants went down while rents went up
Between 2002 and 2005 stabilized rents rose by over 8% while incomes for stabilized tenants went down by 8.6% (to a median household income of $32,000) adjusted for inflation to 2004 dollars.
Rent stabilized tenants now have a gross rent-to-income ration of almost 32%
The real median hourly wage went down between 2000 and 2005 by almost 5%
• Housing conditions have worsened while rents went up
A recent city survey reveals that in 2005 over 75,000 occupied apartments had 5 or more serious maintenance deficiencies, and 110,000 apartments had experienced 4 or more heating breakdowns.
HPD currently shows 2.8 million uncorrected violations. The city’s code enforcement activities are unequal to the problem: 75% of maintenance violations go uncorrected in any given year.
While fuel costs went up, heat complaints to 311 were at record levels (during a comparatively mild winter). The city received between 30,000 and 63,000 heat and hot water complaints each month during the 2005/2006 heat season.
The Real Estate Industry:
Owners of rent-regulated housing are earning generous incomes.
• The 2004 Income and Expense data (most recent available) showed net operating incomes increased from 37.8 to 38 percent. This gain occurred despite the price index surge of 16.9 percent that year. This year, the price index of 7.8 percent is half what was in 2004.
• Owners have continued to benefit from a good lending environment despite an interest rate increase of .79 percentage point. Mortgage lenders reported to the RGB that they had experienced virtually no non-performing loans or foreclosures.
Sources: The NYC Rent Guidelines Board 2006 Reports (Income and Affordability; Mortgage Survey; Income and Expense); The 2005 Housing & Vacancy Survey; the Fiscal Policy Institute; the Furman Center for Real Estate and Urban Policy, New York University, the FY2006 Mayor’s Management Report; “Inequitable Enforcement” by the Association of Neighborhood and Housing Development and the Public Advocate; “Closing the Door: Accelerating Losses of New York City Subsidized Housing” by the Community Service Society.
Rent Regulation and The Division Of Housing and Community Renewal
http://www.gothamgazette.com/article/housing/20060523/10/1867/
This is just a little memo to the rent increases from one citizen to others. There is a big big problem about to happen I live in affordable housing and I cant afford this right now. When they said our rent was going up projected three years and I figured that with this being a working community, We will be okay. No this is not kjay a predominately working community is struggling. I am the President of the Tenants Association here and know that the community is in bad shape to come.
Come Testify about Your Rents – Attend one of the Public Hearings below.
Call the RGB to Register to speak: 212-385-2934
Monday, June 19, 2006
4:00 P.M. – 10:00 P.M.
Main Theatre of Hostos Community College / CUNY
450 Grand Concourse, Bronx, NY 10451
Map and Directions
or Thursday, June 22, 2006
10:00 A.M. – 6:00 P.M.
The Great Hall at Cooper Union
7 East 7th Street at corner of 3rd Ave. (Basement)
Map and Directions
Protest at the Final Vote
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
5:30 P.M. – 9:30 P.M.
The Great Hall at Cooper Union
7 East 7th Street at corner of 3rd Ave. (Basement)
RGB: Rent Gouging Bastards
By Bennett Baumer
Since your article mentions my name twice. I just thought I would respond. I regret that I was not reappointed to the RGB this year. I have never been told by either the Mayor (who at least had the courtesy to send me a “”non -reappointment letter” ) or Marvin Marcus, who showed a total lack of class by not calling or writing to me, that I was not being reappointed. As emboldened” as Markus may be when yelling down tenant advocates, apparently he was not up to the courtesy of a phone call or a note to someone who is determined, was not in lockstep with his thinking.
As a Public Member of the RGB, and based upon my instructions from the Mayor when I first met with him during my interview prior to appointment to the RGB, I was supposed to do my due diligence, look at both sides of the issues, and “vote my conscience.” While I came onto the RGB with a very open mind, I ulitmately felt that the reseach, the proceedings, the evaulation of comparable hardships imposed on owners and tenants, were all slanted against the tenant. I was proud that, in many instances, I was able to persude at least five other Board members to support positions that Markus opposed . It would not be unreasonable to suggest that Markus feared my influence. Even though he controlled the majority of the Board, he did not control me. My “political” inexperience resulted in my non reappointment. I guess if I had kowtowed to Markus, I would still be on the Board? No thanks!
But I am [pleased that at least for two years, I was able to lead the fight for “0%” rent increases for the SRO and Hotels, and that I was the only Public Member to ever vote against a rent increase..and that I was one of a few of the Borad members who fought to move meetings out of Manhattan and into the other Boros. My biggest disappointment was that while the RGB held its last meeting in The Bronx which I had pushed for as a resident from The Bronx,and I had not been invited to the part, so to speak.
So thank you for mentioning me twice. It suggests to me that even though I was not as effective as I had hoped, some of you noticed. Who knows, perhaps when a new Mayor is elected, and that Mayor is more pro tenant, my services might be asked for again.
Sincerely,
Martin Zelnik, RA/AIA
Democracy is not present when people have no say in their affairs. The rent situation in New York City is a prime example lof that. Rent increases are not in the interest of New York Renters, most of whom simply cannot afford their present rents much less continuing increases. Property over people is not democracy.
Here is some press from the Rent Guidelines Board vote.
“residents brace for possible rent increase”
http://www.1010wins.com/pages/3333.php?
June 28th “Evening News”
http://archive.wbai.org/
NYC Indymedia
http://nyc.indymedia.org/en/2006/06/71903.html
Tenants boo board as housing costs jump
http://www.nydailynews.com/06-28-2006/news/local/story/430601p-363029c.html
Rent board got it right, sez Mike
http://www.nydailynews.com/06-29-2006/news/story/430891p-363244c.html
Ritual at the Rent Board, at Higher Volume This Year
By JANNY SCOTT
The annual cycle of meetings of the Rent Guidelines Board is a bizarre rite of spring in New York City — an extravaganza of months of elaborately orchestrated self-expression often compared to a circus. Tenants armed with drums and whistles arrive by the busload. Organizers whip them into a frenzy, which in the end seems to stop just short of hanging the board chairman in effigy.
The final meeting this year, held on Tuesday evening, was one for the record books. For the first time, tenant organizers say, they had decided to try to shut down the meeting. Shouting, chanting, rattling and screaming drowned out the chairman, Marvin Markus, who called a two-and-a-half-hour recess to wait out the crowd. Even when the board finally returned and voted, the members could not hear one another speak.
Tenant organizers, exultant yesterday about the disruption, said they had changed their tactics to show that the rent-regulation system was broken. They want control of the city’s rent laws taken away from the State Legislature and returned to the city. With statewide elections approaching, and support from the City Council speaker and other elected officials, they have begun what they describe as a campaign for rent-law home rule.
”We’re just trying to get this on people’s radar,” said Anne Perryman, president of an association that represents the mostly elderly residents of some 550 rent-stabilized apartments in the Lincoln Towers complex on the Upper West Side. Asked if derailing the meeting was a smart strategy, she said: ”I don’t know. I know it’s our one opportunity every year to be heard. I don’t know how you do it. This is theater here.”
There has long been a stage-managed quality to the annual meetings in which the rent board arrives at adjustments for the city’s one million rent-stabilized apartments. Most meetings begin with a long, cacophonous overture of audience noise. (Mr. Markus did not even attempt to interrupt for 15 minutes.) Audience members wear shirts bearing slogans, chant in unison and wave caricatures of Mr. Markus, an investment banker with wavy silver hair.
People approach the stage to shout directly at members of the board. Television camera operators scurry to capture displays of finger-pointing and fury. At a meeting in April, a woman in a yellow windbreaker and cap, sitting in the front row, shouted out a song that began, ”Marvin Mark-up, Marvin Mark-up” to the tune of ”My Darling Clementine.”
Frank Ricci, director of governmental affairs for the Rent Stabilization Association, which represents building owners and managers, said: ”I’ve never been to a public hearing anywhere where people were allowed to bring in conga drums and metal cans filled with rocks to make noise. Those could have been used as projectiles. You can’t even bring stuff like that into a baseball game, let alone a public hearing.”
Most of the time, Mr. Markus and other board members affect an air of unruffled neutrality. Mr. Markus seems willing to wait for the obligatory uproar to subside. When the agenda includes a vote, it often goes like this: The two members appointed to represent tenant interests propose no rent increase, which is voted down; the two members representing building owners propose a big increase, which is voted down; then one of the five public members proposes something in between, which passes, usually by a vote of 5 to 4. On Tuesday night, the board voted to allow increases of 7.25 percent on two-year leases and 4.25 percent on one-year leases.
The issue, however, became less the proposed increases than home rule — even though the board, appointed by the mayor, does not determine whether the state or the city controls the rent laws. In 1971, the State Legislature passed a law, called the Urstadt Law, after Charles Urstadt, a former state housing commissioner, barring New York City from adopting rent limitations and tenant protections more restrictive than those set by the state.
At the meeting, Adriene Holder, a tenant member, asked Mr. Markus to add to the agenda a proposal that the board pass an ”advisory resolution” in favor of giving control to the city. She said the city was facing the ”worst affordability crisis in the modern era,” in part because of ”three decades of state control.” The board rejected her motion by a vote of 7 to 2, with only the tenant members in favor.
”Why are we not willing to do it?” Mr. Markus said in an interview yesterday. ”It’s not our job to be taking positions on the laws we effectively implement.”
Asked about the administration’s position on home rule, Jordan Barowitz, a spokesman for Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, said: ”The power to change the Urstadt Law lies in Albany. Lobbying the Rent Guidelines Board on this issue is like asking them to change the state’s speed limit.”
Tenant leaders say the issue is being taken seriously for the first time in years. Michael McKee, treasurer of Tenants Political Action Committee, a group he said was devoted to getting Democrats elected to the State Senate and reminding them that tenants are part of their coalition, said the City Council had passed two resolutions in favor of home rule. He said a broad group of housing, community and labor groups was working on the campaign.
”Why is it a good thing?” he said, when asked about shutting down the meeting. ”Because the whole Rent Guidelines Board process is broken. We have to make it clear that this whole process is a sham.”
RGB media
Jun 29, 2006 02:30PM EDT
http://www.indypendent.org/?p=254
http://www.indypendent.org/?p=254
“residents brace for possible rent increase”
http://www.1010wins.com/pages/3333.php?
June 28th “Evening News”
http://archive.wbai.org/
NYC Indymedia
http://nyc.indymedia.org/en/2006/06/71903.html
Tenants boo board as housing costs jump
http://www.nydailynews.com/06-28-2006/news/local/story/430601p-363029c.html
Rent board got it right, sez Mike
http://www.nydailynews.com/06-29-2006/news/story/430891p-363244c.html
NYTimes 6/29/06
Ritual at the Rent Board, at Higher Volume This Year
By JANNY SCOTT
The annual cycle of meetings of the Rent Guidelines Board is a bizarre rite of spring in New York City — an extravaganza of months of elaborately orchestrated self-expression often compared to a circus. Tenants armed with drums and whistles arrive by the busload. Organizers whip them into a frenzy, which in the end seems to stop just short of hanging the board chairman in effigy.
The final meeting this year, held on Tuesday evening, was one for the record books. For the first time, tenant organizers say, they had decided to try to shut down the meeting. Shouting, chanting, rattling and screaming drowned out the chairman, Marvin Markus, who called a two-and-a-half-hour recess to wait out the crowd. Even when the board finally returned and voted, the members could not hear one another speak.
Tenant organizers, exultant yesterday about the disruption, said they had changed their tactics to show that the rent-regulation system was broken. They want control of the city’s rent laws taken away from the State Legislature and returned to the city. With statewide elections approaching, and support from the City Council speaker and other elected officials, they have begun what they describe as a campaign for rent-law home rule.
”We’re just trying to get this on people’s radar,” said Anne Perryman, president of an association that represents the mostly elderly residents of some 550 rent-stabilized apartments in the Lincoln Towers complex on the Upper West Side. Asked if derailing the meeting was a smart strategy, she said: ”I don’t know. I know it’s our one opportunity every year to be heard. I don’t know how you do it. This is theater here.”
There has long been a stage-managed quality to the annual meetings in which the rent board arrives at adjustments for the city’s one million rent-stabilized apartments. Most meetings begin with a long, cacophonous overture of audience noise. (Mr. Markus did not even attempt to interrupt for 15 minutes.) Audience members wear shirts bearing slogans, chant in unison and wave caricatures of Mr. Markus, an investment banker with wavy silver hair.
People approach the stage to shout directly at members of the board. Television camera operators scurry to capture displays of finger-pointing and fury. At a meeting in April, a woman in a yellow windbreaker and cap, sitting in the front row, shouted out a song that began, ”Marvin Mark-up, Marvin Mark-up” to the tune of ”My Darling Clementine.”
Frank Ricci, director of governmental affairs for the Rent Stabilization Association, which represents building owners and managers, said: ”I’ve never been to a public hearing anywhere where people were allowed to bring in conga drums and metal cans filled with rocks to make noise. Those could have been used as projectiles. You can’t even bring stuff like that into a baseball game, let alone a public hearing.”
Most of the time, Mr. Markus and other board members affect an air of unruffled neutrality. Mr. Markus seems willing to wait for the obligatory uproar to subside. When the agenda includes a vote, it often goes like this: The two members appointed to represent tenant interests propose no rent increase, which is voted down; the two members representing building owners propose a big increase, which is voted down; then one of the five public members proposes something in between, which passes, usually by a vote of 5 to 4. On Tuesday night, the board voted to allow increases of 7.25 percent on two-year leases and 4.25 percent on one-year leases.
The issue, however, became less the proposed increases than home rule — even though the board, appointed by the mayor, does not determine whether the state or the city controls the rent laws. In 1971, the State Legislature passed a law, called the Urstadt Law, after Charles Urstadt, a former state housing commissioner, barring New York City from adopting rent limitations and tenant protections more restrictive than those set by the state.
At the meeting, Adriene Holder, a tenant member, asked Mr. Markus to add to the agenda a proposal that the board pass an ”advisory resolution” in favor of giving control to the city. She said the city was facing the ”worst affordability crisis in the modern era,” in part because of ”three decades of state control.” The board rejected her motion by a vote of 7 to 2, with only the tenant members in favor.
”Why are we not willing to do it?” Mr. Markus said in an interview yesterday. ”It’s not our job to be taking positions on the laws we effectively implement.”
Asked about the administration’s position on home rule, Jordan Barowitz, a spokesman for Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, said: ”The power to change the Urstadt Law lies in Albany. Lobbying the Rent Guidelines Board on this issue is like asking them to change the state’s speed limit.”
Tenant leaders say the issue is being taken seriously for the first time in years. Michael McKee, treasurer of Tenants Political Action Committee, a group he said was devoted to getting Democrats elected to the State Senate and reminding them that tenants are part of their coalition, said the City Council had passed two resolutions in favor of home rule. He said a broad group of housing, community and labor groups was working on the campaign.
”Why is it a good thing?” he said, when asked about shutting down the meeting. ”Because the whole Rent Guidelines Board process is broken. We have to make it clear that this whole process is a sham.”